@Andrew Frishman @Ken Virzi I'm part way through a process that I would consider a mostly BRRRR strategy...
Found a house on the MLS in my hometown. Meant to use it just as a normal primary residence but discovered BP along the way and I've got the bug hard now, so the strategy has changed a bit.
Asking price was 89,900. Agent negotiated for me down to 86,900, and the seller paid the closing costs. 3 bed 2 bath. 1700 sq ft. about a 100 yr old house. I used the first time homebuyer grant (not sure if that is a state or federal thing?) for $5000, with the stipulation that I have to live in the home for five years or will have to pay that back at a pro-rated amount. I got a 3% down 30 year ARM that started at 5.25%. We closed in August of 2018. I had to bring $4.35 to the closing :)
Since closing, I have painted the outside, removed piles of branches and rocks from the backyard, had six trees taken out to clean up a corner of the yard that was otherwise useless, and began tearing out the plaster and lath walls upstairs. There is a room without a closet that while I have the walls down I'm going to build a closet space so I can refinance it as a 4 bed 2 bath. I will also be having an electrician add more outlets and double check that the knob and tube is completely replaced (inspections came back that it was but double checking), plus I will re-insulate all the outside walls before putting up sheet rock. After that, the only thing I will have left is adding gutters before I go to refinance.
I have pulled comps in the area, and unfortunately since I live in such a small town I have seen 4 beds go for anywhere from 85k to 220k. Narrowing the search to ages of homes that are similar, close in size, and the big purchases (roof/HVAC ages), I've come up with a number I think the house is worth, which is about 120k. I feel like that is a conservative estimate, when compared to the other info I have. Hoping for 150k but not banking on it.
If we come back at 120k then I can refi at 80% LTV so my loan will jump to 96k principle from the 83k it is now, but since I will be getting a (much) better interest rate my mortgage payments should be about $50/mo less than they are currently, and I will also be getting that extra 13k cash back...minus the refinance closing costs. I have budgeted 5k for the rehab I described above, so my somewhat conservative estimate is I get back about $5000 in cash free and clear.
The goal is to have this property refinanced by August of 2019, so if all these numbers work out exactly like I just stated, I will have made $5000 to live in this house for a year. I have also house-hacked a little bit by getting my girlfriend moved in with me and paying half the mortgage. So I guess getting technical it would be 5000 cash - 4200 paid in mortgage over a year = 800 free profit.
This is probably a good example of a "base hit" for seasoned investors using the BRRRR method, rather than the home runs most people talk about. I plan to live in this house until my financial situation changes and I buy a nicer primary and will use this as a rental. My best guess is $1200/mo rent which using the BP calc would get me about $300/mo cash flow after I've taken reserves out. But that's probably a couple years down the road.
Also, from an emotional standpoint, can i just take this time to say OMG I AM NEVER DOING A LIVE IN REHAB AGAIN THIS IS SO TERRIBLE I JUST WANT MY HOUSE TO BE PUT BACK TOGETHER