Thanks everyone - Lots of great suggestions and advice!
I bought the church 1 and 1/2 years ago. I have spoken to our local zoning official and he is very helpful and a positive source of help and information!
My full time job is property manager of 15 apartments and I also do the repairs and remodeling and so I'm busy and don't have much time to try to do something with the church.
There's a concept in real estate "what is the highest and best use of this piece of property"
I contacted my local appraiser who appraised the home & church when I bought it and I asked her "could I pay you for an opinion regarding the highest and best use of this piece of property?"
I said "you don't need to write a report, just take a look at this and give me your opinion"
Her response was "uh no thank you" and so I have quietly gone about getting opinions from various programs and agencies such as the local Chamber of Commerce and Small Business Development and Community Funding and Development, my realtor, local real estate investors, and various programs and it's been an interesting process.
Probably the highest and best use of this piece of property is child care.
People are paying $125 per week per child for child care.
Eight kids equals $1,000 per week.
$1,000 per week is "high wages" for this community.
The building is large enough to support a large number of kids.
Sixteen kids per week equals $2,000
Twenty four kids per week equals $3,000
I can't make $3,000 per week turning this into a duplex.
Someone mentioned turning it back into a church and that is a good idea - I like it because it can be done while I'm doing these other things and just have that as additional income!
The other possibility would be to put some money into the building and have it as a wedding venue.
People are paying $1,200 for the use of a venue - FOR THE WEEKEND. They want the venue friday evening to set up and prepare, then have the wedding on Sat, and then come back and clean up the next day in order to receive their deposit.
Again, I want to thank everyone for their suggestions and input!