Hi all, looking at picking up my first B&R. I live in a very rural area of South Dakota with very limited comps and even fewer rehab comps. However, refinancing has been hot and I have been hearing that appraisals are coming back better than expected.
This property has a ton of potential. The main floor has two bedrooms and 1 bath. One bedroom currently has a shower and toilet installed which will be removed, the previous owners had a hospice situation. Additionally the entire first floor is hardwood which is in pretty good condition. I plan to have it resurfaced. The kitchen is a complete gut, the bathroom is in good shape and the shower from the bedroom is entirely usable so i intend to just move it into the bathroom and do some light repairs.
Where things get interesting is the potential for more in this home. There is an upstairs loft which only needs to be finished to be counted as a bedroom. Additionally the basement is in great shape and once cleaned and demo'd has plenty of potential to turn this into a duplex. Even better a sperate entrance to the basement is already in place.
Where i'm struggling is determining a healthy scope of work. I will get this property at around 30k, i estimate that repairs to the main floor might run me to 25k on the high end. Much of the dmeolition, painting, cleaning, I will complete my self. I have no doubt that my ARV will be 60k+ with rental estimates in the 500-700 range.
For an additional 30k I could turn this property into a duplex... my worry is that I would have almost zero comps available and homes just don't sell above 140k in this town so i'm not sure I would be able to get my investment back out. Going this route would easily bring rents around 1100 between the units.
My plan currently is to purchase the property, do the main floor renovation, clean and demo the basement, and refi back out while renting. This leaves me the opportunity to analyze the additional renovations down the line while also gives a potential buyer the freedom to use this entire space as a SFH if I ever want to sell.