Thanks for the responses! No offense to anybody here, but I don't like to use property managers.
@Jay HinrichsYes, HR is definitely an option but I haven't had much luck with finding properties there that would equal my cash flow. I will start looking harder in the next few weeks to see if anything new has popped up on the market.
@Benjamin Herrmann I fell out of the 2 of 5 year window two years ago, so that's out. I wish though!
@Derrick Aragon I'd be interested in hearing what you have in mind for structuring the sale...PM coming.
@Mike H. My gut feeling does say to just pay the taxes. Total tax bill, according to my CPA, will be in the $40-50k range. I also like the way you think about recouping that tax money on the next deal!
Due to the price appreciation of the duplex, I think I'll be able to use the proceeds from the sale (after taxes) to fund another property closer to me that will come close to the cashflow I'm currently getting...but I will own it outright. That alone might make paying the taxes worth it to me!