My business partner & I always have this same discussion. He is a real estate appraiser and when we are listing a property for rent he will always evaluate it like a good appraiser does. I always laugh at him and jack the rent up about 25% above his max rate and I usually are able to sign a tenant. I always argue its not the market and the MLS that sets the average gained rents its the section 8 recipients with their vouchers. Its like free money to them as it is based on number of kids and how much (or mostly little) they work. around here, 2 kids gets you $1500, 3 kids $1800, 5 kids 2500. I can easy rent a TH for $1800 that usually goes for $1400 when you rent it to people who actually work for a living. The $$ are deposited in my account every month and so far, I have had minimal trouble with the tenants. They know a good thing and don't want to be kicked out of the program. When they sign the lease we highlight on the first page...no pets, no smoking and we sent reports and problems back to section 8 concerning tenant issues. Besides the inevitable "I know you said no pets but can we get a PittBull" question everything goes mostly smooth.
Heres to section 8. The thought of it really pisses me off but it makes my bank account happy.