Spencer Keables , I am also a SLC, enthusiast as I worked there for a few years out of college and my wife has family there. This was before I had any RE experience or interest.
I now work for a multifamily company so my post is based on larger properties than you mentioned. I was shocked watching a national multifamily conference from Marcus and Millichap where SLC was trading at such incredibly low cap rates. There was NYC at around 4.0% some of the other "Sexy 6" as they call them ( Boston, DC, Seattle, Los Angeles, and San Francisco.) Salt Lake City was right there at like 4.8% I almost fell out of my chair in disbelief.
---------------------------------------------------
As for your 1% or 2% maybe your not looking for the right opportunity. What if you found a deal that was not at 1% but through renovation and upgrades you could release the units to meet that rule.
Quick example the first deal I ever closed for my company was a 3 unit in South Side of Pittsburgh. I cold called the owner and worked the deal off market. We paid $197k when total rents were $1,400 a month. All units were 2/1's.
We invested about $7,500 per unit in renovations and framed in a doorway so now the units were 3/1's. Each unit rented at $1,200 the first year and now $1,250.
Purchase Price plus renovations: $219,500 or .7% based on rents at purchase.
One year later monthly rents $3,600 or 1.96% almost 2%.
It's basically how a house flipper purchase a house right, you negotiate based on what you currently have, but your plan and execution makes the deal OK, GOOD, or GREAT.
I was in SLC for Christmas and let me tell you there is a TON of Opportunity there if you see things through a different lense. My friend was telling me he was renting a few blocks away from Desert Edge (close to 500S 500 E) a 2/1 for $650, and 4 blocks away a new class A building renting 1 Bdrms for $1,150. That's is a GIGANTIC spread, you should be able to upgrade your 2/1 with all the latest accessories and top of line finishes for about $12k per door. This 2 BDRM would rent at minimum for $1,000 (again I don't know the market, just going of past experience and feel). But it's a fair assumption assuming you invest the money on the rehab.
What would happen to your ratios if rents almost doubled?
As someone mentioned if anyone in SLC is interested in talking about prospecting and cold calling I am all ears, this is what we specialize in and are quite good at it. Let me tell you a lot of dilapidated 5-25 unit buildings in downtown SLC, buildings look old, just as I am sure their owners are, old and tired.
I have kicked the idea with my boss about a call center, I know I can train people and get deals going quickly, if nothing we could wholesale some multis and make a quick buck. If anyone is interested let's chat.