@John Leavelle
It's a triplex. I've been looking at a number of properties, one of which is a duplex so I think I just misspoke. I was tired when I composed the post. The triplex was built in 1986. A duplex I'm looking at and mentioned was what has been remodeled. Sorry about the mix up.
And I agree that my time is worth something. My thought with self-managing is to learn the business and then once I acquire more properties and am ready to transfer those responsibilities, I'll be in a better position to hire someone as I'll know what the work is like. It's a good idea to plan for it in my numbers though.
I have run across a number of properties with similar cash flow results. I've built a spreadsheet that I can drop info into so in five minutes I have a comparison. I'm also scheduling visits to some of these properties so that I can get a better sense of values and rents which will help me to recognize the diamond in the rough.
I have a single family (3 bed/1 bath) that I'm scheduled to see that is priced at $18,900 but I'm certain it needs work. The neighborhood is full of similar houses and as far as I can tell sell in the $50-60k range. This would probably be a BRRR.