@Andrew Michaud I understand your concern. I assume you are talking about Limestone, Washburn, or Fort. Not only is the tenant pool in these towns typically low but the quality of tenant is potentially low as well. So you're not only looking at finding tenants but hopefully finding good ones. Don't discount the amount time you will have to spend in managing all of this if the tenant is not right and put that into the equation. I don't know if you have a full time job or not but management on top of work can get old fast for small returns.
I find one of the keys to getting good tenants in this area, and something that is slowly becoming a trend around here, is to offer something other then the norm. And that would be a nice, clean, updated apartment. I don't know if you've had the opportunity to look at any of the inventory in this area but most is old, worn, and outdated. I have had numerous potential tenants complain of this and get super excited to see something new. They are willing to pay more for this as well. Relatively inexpensive updates, if you can do the work yourself can go a long way. Floors, paint, vanities, kitchen cabinets. Also there seems to be a lack of exceptional service when it comes to landlording. Good communication, prompt responses to calls and emails, and getting problems taken care of quickly are something that people are not used to, extremely pleased with, and can go a long way. Essentially run it like a business that you really want to succeed. If you can do these things and gain a good reputation and network, then you can fill these units with good people.
Now the numbers themselves don't look bad. I like the high appraisal and the large amount of immediate equity that you would have. You could ultimately use this equity for money down on more buildings in either Caribou or Presque Isle area where you wouldn't have to worry about vacancies as much, could be a little more selective on what you're purchasing, and be in a position to jump at any opportunities that may arise. You could also use some of that to update the two vacant units you would have and get on the path to transforming that building and offering something different. Anyway I could go on and on. Hope this helps