Here we are 3 years later and my neighbor just sold through Homie and lost 20k in the transaction. The agent who is rarely reachable didn't have the expertise to procure a buyer who was able to pay the offer price without being subject to appraisal for loan purposes and since my neighbor was already under contract on another home couldn't start over in the process and had to simply knock 20k off of the price to meet the appraisal which was FHA and sticks with the property for months. A skilled agent who was on top of their market would've countered to prevent this but most average sellers have no idea what they are sacrificing going with a flat fee discount broker.
And to be fair, agents are for the most part willing to negotiate their commissions and this 5 or 6% is not a standard. Furthermore, the cost to list a home, pay the dues, marketing, open houses, TIME, contract expertise, continuing education, and all the other expenses and then self employment taxes, agents often barely survive. Something like 98% drop out in the first few years and the rest are making an average of 40k according to online data.
I think you run a huge risk going with a non relationship based broker. You just don't know what help you're going to get after you sign on the line. '
I think the OP did the smart thing. I've done the same for my clients. If I'm helping them purchase, I sell their current home at near cost. It's not making me rich by any means but I'm protecting my client's interest and feel good at the end of the day.