I have an option to do a full cash out refi or partial cash out refi. Here are the numbers with my particular situation but first my question. Which one? ....all based on 400K value and also taking into account receiving 70% of total value for each option.
On the property that I am considering for a cash-out refi, I pay $1638. Taxes, Insurance, HOA, P&I. I receive $2200 monthly rental and have been now for about three years. It stays rented. I could do a partial taking $153K for 30 years @ 5.375% plus 5K for closing costs. The partial would pay off the 93K, current left owing and give me the $60k for the down payment on the investment. Nothing out of pocket. New mortgage payment with taxes, insurance, HOA would be approx $1400. Leaving approx $800 which I would throw toward the principal. This option leaves me about $247K equity still in the place.
Or option two - full cash out refi. Mortgage would be $280K, 93K for payoff on the original, 60K for downpayment on the new investment and walk with $127K in pocket. The new monthly payment for 30 years would be approx $2085, everything. Remember I am collecting $2200 monthly rent. This option leaves me about $120 equity remaining.
I am more comfortable with option #1.
Please weigh in with your comments.