Yes I meant 1 years worth of rent! The tenant was absolutely adamant on staying no matter what and they treated the whole situation very very personal. Others simply don't care, they'll take the offer of a couple months rent and leave.
I don't think the new ONtario rules apply here as you're not asking them to leave for personal use, so it's up to you and your tenant to decide what's fair.
Your #'s look pretty good, I rarely find a true cap rate around 6% so if that area goes for around that cap rate you're already in good shape.
Even if a few of the tenants don't agree to move right away at 5.8% cap your're still in pretty good shape and you can slowly work on it. If you do have to get aggressive with your cash for keys offers it's still worth it as your upside is very high.
The way I see it is if you can get an extra $450/mo per unit that's $5400 in your first year paid back, you can recoup your costs very very quickly. The increased value is a complete bonus. If you're confident there's demand in the area and you can sell at around 1.3m or maybe refinance if you ever decided to, I'd get aggressive if needed. Start off low and renovate as they leave and maybe keep increasing the offer amounts if people stop leaving.
This is a great find, if you find any more like this shoot me a message!