Definitely agree with getting multiple bids. Very good point. I'm familiar with commercial /institutional construction projects (I'm an architect in DC). Since I like Baltimore as an investment market I'll be getting my license in MD soon. I'm comfortable with establishing the scope of work but not familiar with residential/smaller GC companies and would not sign a contract without an attorney reviewing it.
I was talking with my realtor. I told her if the property I was interested were a lot less expensive I may be interested. She suggested we submit a letter of intent (non binding) to gage their interest in the lower number before submitting an offer.
I lowered the price 17K and asked for closing cost. This gave me a cash on cash return of 17% with an 8% cap rate (87500 offer)
I used a rent rate of 1250. Even if I could only rent it for 1200/mo the Cash on cash return would be 14% and 8% cap rate. Both figures include reserves for maintenance, cap ex, vacancy and PM.
This seems like a good return.
If I bought a property and rehabbed it for a total 75K-80K. I would need to be able to ask more a month for it to give me a better return since my interest rate on that loan would be higher.
I agree with Seth that the turn key would be far less work and there is value to that. Since this would be my first project, having the property basically ready for rent is appealing. I will need to get the lead certificate/ testing done and I would probably paint...but that it's barring anything that would come up in the inspection.
What would be good to know is how much more rent you could get with central air in that part of town for the same home. Many of the house ads I look at have comparable homes but they aren't exactly the same. What sells? Is the higher rent due to central air or the extra full bath or the newer kitchen. There is no formula I know.
I understand Rich's point about buying below market and adding value as well.
p.s when the agent sent the letter of intent they asked for a formal offer...