Originally posted by @Spencer Hollen:
Sue I am currently in the same boat as you. I am performing a 1031 Exchange out of California and reinvesting just over a million in property in Arizona. I have a second business that I manage outside of my real estate business, so managing more than two properties is really out of the question for me.
I initially was looking at houses in the million dollar range, but I found the cap rates to be very low compared to what you spend. They were in the range of $4500 a month for houses in excess of $900,000, when houses in the $700,000 range were renting for $3800-4000/month. After looking into that I have decided to split my investment into two separate houses. One in a C class neighborhood in Phoenix in the range of 250k +/- and one other house in the Scottsdale/Cave Creek area for 750k. That will also help because houses in B/C class neighborhoods tend to rent much more quickly than houses in A neighborhoods.
I would be interested to hear what you decide to do as I also opted for a lower ROI, but a less time consuming investment. I know I could make 6k + a month with 5 houses in Phoenix and keep them rented out, but the amount of work/repairs/screening involved would exceed my time. Cheers. I wish you luck.
This is a smart strategy, and I wanted to offer you some encouragement for your decision. It is always smart to diversify your portfolio, and choosing properties in different price ranges is just smart investing.
As a Realtor in Arizona for over 20 years, I have seen different strategies work, but yours is pretty solid.
Sue, to your situation, I would suggest looking in parts of North Scottsdale as well as Desert Ridge. These areas offer good "bubbles" of social activity (not to be confused with a real estate bubble). What I mean is that renters are attracted to these areas because they are in close proximity to where they will buy groceries, shop, eat out, and entertain themselves. Kierland, as an example, is a popular community in North Scottsdale, and has a great bubble with both Kierland and Scottsdale quarter nearby. The rental rates are solid, and there would be opportunities to do different things with the property down the road, if you like, like post it on airbnb and so forth (they have co-hosts that do all the work for you). Additionally, this community has been sought after since it's inception in the 1995-1996 year range.
As a side note to your 1031 exchange...make sure you check with your accountant about what 'like for like' means. You mentioned different types of property, and not all of them would follow the rules of a 1031 exchange necessarily, so you would want to be clear on that.
Lastly, has either of you considered a property manager? This may eliminate your original problem of not having the time/energy to manage the properties yourself. Sure, they may take up to 10%, but it sounds like you are leaving money on the table by short-changing your ROI. It's very possible that even with the expense of the property manager, you may still be better off. And remember, the property manager's fee is tax deductible. Just a thought.
I hope that helps. Best of luck to both of you!