@Jennifer Turner is spot on because for those who think FL is a great, the costs are rising rapidly. Insurance for one has almost doubled. Taxes and HOA fees are coming up too. But for those who love VA, they have not seen the tax bill, and repair costs. A little problem with a property will leave you easily with a hefty bill and eat away at your returns. Surely VA will likely give you a higher appreciation over time. Go back to what your goal is with your this investment and see if the math works. Perhaps the best advice might be from someone who suggested pick the house that will be close to you so if anything you can self manage and learn. But I will also add if I had this 300K or 400K, I would go with VA because of location. In a downturn, you will likely to rebound faster than Gainesville(But keep in mind I have no in depth market of Gainesville- there could be a large company coming there and that would change everything)