Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Christian Hutchinson

Christian Hutchinson has started 45 posts and replied 346 times.

Post: Starting up as a new investor... multiple small SFH vs 1 large?

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354
Originally posted by @Matt Kelty:

@Jamiel Strickland

Thanks for the suggestion. I’m looking more in Genesee county vs northern Oakland, not Detroit proper.

I guess my question was more along the lines of, if you had $120k (as a talking number) to invest, would you look at one larger more expensive SFH or multiple small lower income SFHs? In the end the monthly cash flow could be close to the same, but you may be able to get more properties for less than the cost of 1 in a nicer town. Is there a pro or con to either situation?

Thanks again.

 This is always a challenge for people.  I would do 2 homes at the 40-60K range thats in solid working class cities/suburbs.  Unless you have some real know how don't go low-income, there are too many variables.  Now if you have a family friend, a close friend, or someone who just willing to help you, and will help you score 5-8 properties in Flint and get them tenanted.

Get 2 places see if you like it, build up some more cash, and go more aggressive in your 2nd round of buying. I think at your pricepoint there might be some deals to be had in places like Waterford, Romeo, Holly, maybe even Fenton or Lapeer.

Originally posted by @Jason Mazza:

This spring I purchased my first Duplex in Metro Detroit (Center Line) for 93k. After listening to the BP Podcasts for just over a year I finally jumped in at age 23 and bought a duplex with a 5% down owner occupied loan. I did about 12k worth of rehab including a new kitchen, bath and refinished hardwood floors. After completing the rehab, I moved into the upper 1 bedroom unit and posted the lower unit on Zillow, hotpads, etc. I was surprised to get many hits on my posts within the first day at $925 a month (almost 1% rule with only 1 of the units rented)! With my PITI totaling $720 and managing the property myself, I am comfortably getting paid to live! Within a few months, I plan to move out and rent the upper unit and get another small multi with an OO loan once I hit the 12-month mark.

Once both units are rented and I pass it off to property management, here are what the stats will look like assuming 7% Capex, 7% vacancy, 10% PM, 5% repairs:

COC: 18%

Monthly Cash Flow: $300

ARV: $125000

Special thanks to BP User Bill Goodland for your coaching during the entire process. Also, to the BP team for the Michigan State-Specific LL forms.

 Might be tough to get a second mortgage.  Your rental income must be aged two years for it to count, so when doing Debt Income ratios now, they count $100% of the debt and 0% of the revenue.  Now if you purchased way under your maxvand you can find another home thats a duplex in a similar price-point keep rolling by all means

Post: Buy & Hold Investing in Hamtramck, MI

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354
Originally posted by @Andrew Combs:

Hi all,

I'm currently looking to start investing in the Detroit area from out of state -- small MFH or SFH for buy & hold rental. I'm looking in a few mile wide area around the city including suburbs and looking to spend between $75-140k w/ minor rehab. I have some family in Royal Oak that are helpful for giving me on-the-ground impressions of areas/homes, but am curious on BP folks' thoughts. I've looked through many of the other posts on Detroit, but haven't seen much mentioned about Hamtramck, which is an area that is currently catching my eye. Any thoughts on Hamtramck or other possible neighborhoods/suburbs that could fit my investment criteria would be much appreciated. Thanks!

 If you want to rent in Hamtramck know how to speak:

  • Polish
  • Albanian
  • Tamil
  • Bengali
  • Arabic (Yemen/Saudi based)

I've found a few nice deals in Mexicantown, but I self manage and when 80% of the population speaks Spanish it can be difficult, so I backed off. I'm trying to rent a house out in Sterling Heights and 1/2 the prospects speak Arabic or Assyrian.  I am communicating with the kids and not the prospects because they of a language barrier.

If you want in early somewhere you can get a steal north of indian/west village or try to get a steal along Jefferson east of Indian village but west of the Chrysler plant. SFH and MFH to be had for under $50K. All the neighborhoods you mentioned came off the board 2-3 years ago investment wise. Also, take a look at Fraser it has solid schools and things come out under $100K periodically. It would be a solid B-Rental.

Post: House Hack or Starter Home?

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354

Househack, in 3-4 years save the money you would have put towards your mortgage you will have 30-50K.
That changes your life situation pretty good.

6-12 months prepaid rent.

I call my "public servant special". (Teachers, police, state/federal jobs)Appointment/offer letter plus 3 months pre-paid.

Originally posted by @Matthew John:

@Christian Hutchinson Sounds like you got a steal! I'm going to go after this guy with an offer and see if he'll bite. 

How do you like the area in Roseville compared to others in Metro Detroit?

 We were looking in Roseville extensively this fall. Our Roseville Duplex has been very stable. The City has been easy to work with.  I really like that property, we really leveraged our position against the seller to get a favorable price (they wanted ($109K) but we presented an offer at $65K and I submitted several data points with the offer to justify the price.  The Seller countered at $79K.  We took it.  Then the appraisal came in at $67K. We almost walked away from the deal, we did in-fact for 3-4 days.  Then after a family meeting, I said convinced it made sense to go underwater for a property we will be holding 5-10 years for just $6K.  We asked to close at $73K, then we made up the difference.

We ultimately this Fall went into St. Clair Shores. I wanted Roseville but was overruled, because of a more desired just short of turnkey property.

Roseville because of its price-point and location has a deep renter pool. What we have found is we get a TON of activity on our property listing.  Its staggering.  Lots of the leads are just not qualified being just don't show up, short of income, have issues with a previous eviction, want Section 8, unsteady/unverifiable income, are qualified but won't turn in an application, are qualified but you realize they will be a headache to deal with.  You have to really wait on the right tenant.  Because of market there I really make an effort to show every single person the place that inquires because you just don't know until you see them and their paperwork. I typically say for every 4 people who I show a property I get an application.  Roseville this property its closer to 8-10 people. IRoseville is a great rental city, but as a landlord you can't get lazy on screening, because of the demographics of the area the margin of error between a bad applicant or good applicant is razor thin.

Originally posted by @Matthew John:

@Christian Hutchinson Wow! Tons of value. Interesting that you don't deal with siding, all my other deals in this area have been siding & not brick. 

The owner is an international investor. They bought it for 95k in 2016 now trying to sell for 150k?? 

I wasn't sure, since it's a triplex, if you need 3 furnaces + hot water tanks or if 1 works for the whole building. That's where I was struggling with estimating a budget. 

130k sounds about right, but he wants a 6 year note. I was going to try and negotiate that for 3 years at 7%. Might be hard to find a bank that'll loan 4.25% on an investment property. I keep hearing rates of 5.75% nowadays which makes 7% on a LC not sound that bad. 

 Call Consumers Energy/DTE and they will tell you.

But based on the pictures you have 3 meters for gas and 3 for electric. plus the listing says tenants pay all their utilities.  So you could replace every furnace for $5K total furnance for that size unit is $900, I saw one water meter. Either way its $600/HWT installed. Those are individual prices, done in a grouping probably would save 15%.


We bought in Summer 2014 for $73K we just had an valuation done in Sept, and it came in 146K high, 95k low, and value 121K.  This is for a brick side by side duplex on .6 acre lot with full basements.  One unit is 1b/1ba the other is 2b/1.5ba, one unit has a 2 car detached garage.


Originally posted by @Matthew John:

@Christian Hutchinson Roseville - The numbers aren't bad, but it will definitely need some big items replaced. I do think 6 years on a LC is way too long to wait, so he's going to have to negotiate if he wants to sell. 

Pretty much everything around here was 1920s - 1950s in Warren/Roseville area. 

Are you still looking to buy in this market?

So I just pulled the listing. We are always looking to buy, but this place doesn't interest me because its vinyl siding. Just a thing with how we buy.

I have a 2Bed room with a basement and garage at 696 and Gratiot (Glendale) thats $900/mo

I have a 1bedroom we rent for $750 own driveway, basement on the other-side of the Duplex.

We put in Central Air 3 years ago.

Depending on the layout you might have a value-add situation here.  It might be poor management combined with absentee owner.  We have no Section 8 tenants.

Do not commit to keeping those tenants. You are leaving $50-$100 per unit/mo on the table. Honor their lease and get market rate payers.  I would just spiffy up the units a bit upgrade the appliances, upgrade the kitchen OR bathroom.

A furnace on that size home is $2200, HWT is $600, a full tear-off roof might run you $6K, those windows look newer, that not a problem. Its on a slab so foundation issues are moot.

This is a value add play.  Make an offer strong enough to get a look inside bring your contractor with you.  Then hammer the price on any issues.
I'd offer $130K with a $10K EMD, use land contract to close quickly, pay him 6 months then refi to cheaper long term money with a bank, 4.25% at 15 years ($1100/mo for MTI vs $800/mo for 30 years).

Actually refi once you upgrade the units. then remove the current tenants.

Originally posted by @Matthew John:

@Steve Hodgdon Wow! Good thing you did your due diligence. Hearing those prices in your market sounds crazy because in Metro Detroit you can get a 30 unit for 1.3 million. 

In my area, all the houses are older, especially the multi families. 

They said they updated electrical and 90% of the plumbing 12 years ago, but also did the rest of the CapEx. I figure in the next few years it will need roof, furnace, water heaters, driveway so I'm going to present them $115k and see if they want to talk. If not, onto the next one. It'll be a tough sell if they won't let anyone inside!

 What part of town? built in 1920 I would be checking the windows, settling of the foundation, and the clay pipes to the street breaking down.

Central air in a triplex is no big deal, just get each unit some windows units and call it good.

Also, the fact its Section 8 means cosmetically its probably decent. I assume the knob and tube wiring is gone and you have newer plumbing lines.

I would take his financing pay him for 6 months and then secure traditional financing via a bank.  Also, I would low ball him, but offer him some extra money down to make him feel better about it.

Post: Starting Out - Spouse NOT on board. What do I do? HELP!

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354
Originally posted by @Kevin Christensen:

BP,

I am in the education phase right now.  I am consuming every drop of information I can via reading, blogs, podcasts, YT, etc.  I am ready to move forward with my first property as soon as the first of the year, maybe sooner if we can close within 30 days around Christmas time.  My issue is, my spouse is not driven for long term goals like I am.  She wants to enjoy our money that we've worked hard for, while our kids are young, and make memories.  To her, that is more important than long term wealth.  We aren't promised tomorrow.  Before anyone clowns about finding a new wife, we've been together almost 18 years and she is my best friend.  No amount of money is worth losing her.  With that said, have any of you gone through this type of struggle early in your real estate journey and overcome it?  I am not worried about getting her involved.  I am worried about her being friction in between me and MY goals.  She is super supportive of my mindset and my goals, she just doesn't support things that cause time to be taken away from family stuff or money to be hoarded that could be used for memories.  I really appreciate everyone's feedback.  

 If your spouse is not on board with something like this it makes it much tougher.  That will cause much stress in your marriage.  Then if things go sideways (and they always do in Real Estate) having an all-in partner is ideal.

I'll use my personal situation.  My Father is remarried for 17 years.  He is the breadwinner, they have no kids together. His Wife retired 6 years ago, he plans to retire Sept 2019. She wanted and has spent her and his money on "experiences", dinners, trips, workshops, etc.  Well My Dad took some money from his 401K and has purchased a few properties.  We went in on some together.  His wife was adamantly opposed. Mind you I handle all the management, she isn't on any mortgages, etc.

Well a few months ago she had a major medical event. She is now unable to clean, cook, drive, etc.  Well My Dad took that money from the rental property profits and pays people to help her weekly get those things done. With her major medical event my Dad had a road to Damascus  moment with his own mortality and we engaged in an extensive estate planning, medical will, advanced directive. Lets say with this unexpected turn of events that fact his RE Investments are 4x value of original investment, and generating 2500/mo in cashflow.  They are really helping him get through this rough time considering his Wife had no cash reserves, long-term care insurance, etc. Also, she took no issue with spending the profits on whatever new shiny object they she saw on TV or at someone's house prior to her medical event.

What I'm basically saying you know your Wife and you think about the future, and how its shaped.  Sometimes you have to act unilaterally in the people you love's best interest even before they realize it. I imagine you are really thinking you need some steady income, and some assets of value as you age, and you are considering RE.  I would look into a range of financial products too that meet that goal.