Originally posted by @Jeremiah B.:
@Daniel Mohnkern cracked me up with his "if you want to call non-investors investors" comment. That's funny, but true.
When you say "real estate investor" I'm reading "wholesaler." That's in no way derogatory, but the challenges of a flipper are very different than those of a wholesaler, and I want to be sure we're talking about the same group.
To some, this may be simply semantics. I know it was to me when I heard Lance Edwards say it for over two years. Now I get it, not that it may make a material difference to many here...
"Investors" put money to work. If you don't have your own money in a deal making a passive return, you aren't investing. Wholesaling, fix/flip, bird dogging, etc. are all considered by the REI community "investing" when they are really "entrepreneuring." Most business cards in the REI community should say "Real Estate Entrepreneur" since very few of the people are "investing". They are buying an asset at a discount, and selling it for a higher price. "Entrepreneur" is not better or worse than "Investor", just more precise terminology.
The asset could be cars, diamonds, construction materials, or any other commodity held in inventory. You don't call a used car dealer an investor, because he isn't. He's a businessman who knows how to acquire a certain asset class at wholesale and develops a model to market to the public at a retail price. He may even be using his own capital to buy his inventory, just like any other small businessman. But again, that doesn't make him an "investor."
So the point is, that if only 5% of the students ever buy their own property, for the very good reasons given, that is only a failure in the initial stages of the REI journey, which is putting knowledge to work capturing wholesale properties to later do something with. They may become interested in "investing" their profits at a later time, or they may become comfortable with the model they have succeeded at and just use their own excess capital to buy their future inventory, for as far as it will take them.
But, bottom line, that RE entrepreneurial work is still a J.O.B. And if they are doing it on the side, they now have two J.O.B.'s. They better be accumulating capital to one day "invest" if they truly intend to exit the rat race.