Originally posted by @Matt Ellis:
So the utilities aren't submetered, not even electricity? That can be crazy especially during the winter if you are running electric heat.
If those are your only 4 line items (insurance, tax, water, electricity) on your pro forma then I would take a step back and reevaluate. Things that I would consider.
Vacancy for the area... why are there 2 vacant units? If the current landlord says he will fill the two spots before the purchase then why hasn't he done it already?
Gas - A lot of chicago has gas heating / boilers... is it sub metered?
Deferred maintenance - If it is selling for less than the 2004 price, has had a period of vacancy in at least two of the units, then I would assume it's a motivated seller because he doesn't want to be in the RE business. In which case, he likely has not taken it upon himself to maintain the property. Have you seen the inside? Does it need a lot of work?
Property management - Someone else mentioned that Englewood is a hard area to operate in for a newbie.. and Chicago in general is not landlord friendly with a lot of small nuances and laws that you need to navigte. Ideally you would have a property management company coaching you through your first property for a year or so.
General maintenance - high maintenance tenants generally imply higher maintenance and turnover costs.
When you say sub-metered are you asking if each unit has individual heaters and furnaces? In that case, they do. All tenants pay their own own gas, electric and heat.
The property manager mentioned they left the newer one open for owner occupancy which is in pristine condition. The second vacant one was recently evicted about a month ago which they are renovating before closing as well.
I have seen the inside of the property, the two occupied units have been there for at least two years and it’s a little dirty which could use cleaning and refurnishing when they choose to move out. But why kick them out if they are loyal tenants.
The basement is not useable because it’s not accessible to tenants and where the heaters and furnaces are located.
If it is wise to hire a property management company, I definitely will if it is the case.