@Nik Krohn, to add the bit on rentals and what we're able to get. Due to the housing shortage, the rental market has done really well too. I'm in Millcreek, UT (Sugar House) and while I could get about $750 last year for a 430 sq. ft. 1 bed/1 bath, we just rolled a new tenant over for $850/mo. We are looking at an Airbnb and Home Away (VRBO) strategy for our 550 sq. ft. 1 bed/1 bath third unit. local averages show we should expect to average $1400/mo. using this strategy. You'll have to look into the laws and regs in Saratoga Springs, but in Salt Lake, we can approach this strategy with a minimum of 1 month agreements which narrows our market, but still creates a greater ROI potential as some traveling workers prefer this type of lease option.
Good Luck with your investments and keep us posted.
@Andy C. I do currently manage my properties and a few others but am not looking to expand at this time. I have heard good things about AAA Property Management but I would not use Evolution Community Management. We've had multiple poor experiences with Evolution. Best of Luck!