@Brie Schmidt
Great idea, I can try to dig up the numbers and present them to him. However, my vacancy rate was zero while I was doing everything my self. I ended up doing an eviction and soon after another tenant just up and left. I found it to difficult to show the units which is when i decided to hire a property manager.
@Steve Rozenberg and @Jean Bolger
My biggest issue is not the expense of the costs. I didn't think anything he has done was unnecessary or too expensive, he has always brought any repairs to my attention and has gotten my approval (no surprises). My biggest concern is tenant management aspect. Is he finding the right tenants (I assume good tenants will bring expenses down)? Is he finding them fast enough? etc. Is it realistic for me to expect good tenants in the lower income area that I'm in?
To my next question; at what point should I try a different property manager and how do I go about it? Do I switch both properties to a new PM (I also own a duplex) or do I just have a new PM manage the more difficult one and if I like them better switch them both?