Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Hannah White

Hannah White has started 1 posts and replied 7 times.

Post: Potential Section 8 tenant, unsure of how to proceed on 1st deal

Hannah WhitePosted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Greenville, SC
  • Posts 7
  • Votes 6
Quote from @Scott Mac:

Taking money Under the Table concurrently with taking money under a government contract---seems like a very scary problem if they find you.

And how much will your attorney fees be if they catch you, and how long might you go to jail for, and how much might they fine you.

Seems like a lot of risk.

Good Luck!

I figured that it is not a good idea, but could not find any information of the legality of a situation like this. I definitely do not want to become a felon off my first deal. I am going to shift away from Section 8 entirely after reading everyones responses. Thank you!

Post: Potential Section 8 tenant, unsure of how to proceed on 1st deal

Hannah WhitePosted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Greenville, SC
  • Posts 7
  • Votes 6
Quote from @Scott Crowley:
Quote from @Hannah White:

@Kevin Sobilo, @Bob Stevens, @Scott Crowley, @Malkia Ra

Thank you for all of your responses. My real estate agent did some market comps for my area and $1,500 was well within the fair market value of properties of the same type. The HUD fair market rent for my area on the federal website is around $1,200. I have been getting a lot of interest in the property, getting several dozens of inquiries about it across many platforms which I feel is good. I try to weed out tenants who won't meet income requirements immediately with my first response being that they must make 3x the monthly rent and pass a credit/background check. About 75% of people don't respond to that or say thanks for your time, which I expected.

Of the 25% that want to move forward, I do showings and they express real interest and then never fill out the application or ghost me. I've only received 3 completed applications, 2 of which had horrible credit history and then the 1 I approved that has the section 8 voucher. I do still have the property listed and am still getting inquiries, but have been holding since we were moving forward with this particular tenant. 

I believe my property is a class B house in a class B neighborhood. I'm in Upstate SC. House is a couple of miles from a local university, within 20 miles of Clemson University and close to many jobs and general amenities such as good restaurants, grocery stores, etc. I had professional pictures taken of the house and am including a washer/dryer with the property.

The reason I have hesitated to do property management is because this is my first deal and I'm trying to save capital to increase profits. My goal is to save every penny I make from this until I can purchase the next property, hopefully within a year or so. Then keep doing that for a few years until it can be really profitable. I had planned to utilize PM once I acquire more properties.

But yes the section 8 thing has me in a predicament. The tenant can afford the $1,500 per month rent based on the employment and income verification that I received with her application. The housing authority is telling me that she cannot based on their standard and that $1,211 is the most they can do with me on a lease agreement with the option to increase the rent after a year. So I am getting conflicting information and have wasted almost 2 weeks with the housing authority trying to get this through. They only told me this today. When I sent in the tenancy approval paperwork to them, it was clearly stated that my rent is $1,500/mo and I feel they should have let me know this was an issue sooner. I apologize for this being so long and thank you all for your time.


 I want you to keep a few things in mind when you read what I'm about to say: 

1) Not even 2 years ago I was as fresh as you are in the game.

2) I am a very cheap person when it comes to my own "doo-dads" and things I don't need...but I am not cheap when it comes to wealth building and investing in income producing assets.

3) While I am still fresh compared to most, I have sec 8 rentals that have been with PM from day 1.

With that being said, I'm going to give it to you straight: Everyone has their own team that works for them and that is fine, but I personally have never seemed to mesh with a RE agent when it comes to rental comps. I've always structured my team to have skin in the game from start to finish where you work with an agent/management operation so it is a constant and ongoing relationship. I've had on-point figures this way so it is worth a mention. 

Believe me, I completely understand your mindset when it comes to trying to save capital for the next investment opportunity(as I said in #2, I am cheap). However, if you pay a good PM as much as 10%/mo and achieve your target of $1,500 then you're only looking at $150/mo or $1,800/yr with the exception of leasing/renewal fees to include in there. I'm sorry but if that amount of capital makes or breaks your next move, things are probably too tight to make a move anyways. It is so easy to be a penny wise and a pound foolish. This pound is the opportunity cost of what you're going through right now that a PM would have not only handled but had someone in your property already. It is also the open door of legal issues you could be walking down.

I cannot emphasize enough how valuable good PM is on your team. They are a phenomenal resource to alleviate you of this exact stress and confusion. If you have a burning desire to self-manage or learn every intricacy of Sec8, at least hire them and learn from the professionals themselves. 

If you are confident in the evaluation of this property being in a class B neighborhood, I would try to avoid sec8 entirely because it may not exactly be necessary to find a strong tenant that qualifies. Maybe if it classifies more as a B- I would be more open to this, though, I don't know your specific market.

Refer to my #3 from earlier. I don't have some mega portfolio of sec8 making me the expert here but I wanted to mention this for one reason: I understand my time is more valuable and honestly, my lack of knowledge is a liability in this arena. Therefore, I would be posing a huge legal and financial risk by thinking I could do it all myself. That is why I never hesitated to have PM from the beginning. The cost of their services is more than fair for the amount of oversight and frontline tasks they engage in. 

You can't mess around on inspections with sec8 either. If you plan on doing that yourself be prepared to go through hoop after hoop to get a passing inspection. They won't approve anything until it meets their standards.

Essentially what I'm saying is this: Make the investment in PM when you know the least about simply anything, Stabilize what you have by surrounding yourself with a solid team(I would be toast already if I didn't do this myself), Don't let dollars and cents cost you thousands in both the short and long-term, and don't put extra liability directly in your hands if you don't understand how to handle it.


 I really appreciate your thoughtful response. After reading everyones comments/suggestions, I am going to move away from Section 8 entirely for the time being. As I just don't have enough experience yet and if I don't work to put better systems in place I'm going to burn down before I even get started.

I also think my RE agent was not super investor friendly and I didn't take enough time to find a quality agent. This is not a mistake I will make in the future. Also as far as the capital, using a PM company would not kill my deal as I paid a decent price for the home and put 20% down. I read Brandon Turners book Real Estate Investing as I was in the process of this home purchase. It put some emphasis on managing your first couple of rentals yourself if you want to do that, then move to PM once more properties are acquired. This seemed like a good idea to me, but I may need to reevaluate.

I am going to do some refocusing of my strategies and make the work better for me. I am so thankful for everyone that responded to my newbie deliemma!

Post: Potential Section 8 tenant, unsure of how to proceed on 1st deal

Hannah WhitePosted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Greenville, SC
  • Posts 7
  • Votes 6
Quote from @Drew Sygit:

Read the HAP contract, it's a federal crime to commit fraud on a S8 lease. At the minimum you would be banned forever from the program.


I haven't gotten a contract or lease yet, as the local housing authority has been very slow with even getting the inspection scheduled. I inferred that it was probably illegal, but couldn't find any information on what that looked like. I'm probably going to shift away from Section 8 completely after reading everyones suggestions as I am not prepared to handle all of this on my first deal. Thank you again.

Post: Potential Section 8 tenant, unsure of how to proceed on 1st deal

Hannah WhitePosted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Greenville, SC
  • Posts 7
  • Votes 6
Quote from @Tim Jacob:

A few things.  1 the time of year is bad.  You said university students are a large part of the tenant base but the best time to lease to them is late spring to mid summer.  If you don't go section 8 I would end the lease then and really spike rent if the tenant wants to go month to month to ensure turnover is in a better time.  

That might be the reason its taking a while.  Options would be lowering the price.  I think if it was priced even a little low it would sell.  Maybe the comps are close but in a slightly better area.  Or lease g was done in a better time.  Either way lowering 100 would not be that bad.  

If it is truly a B area I would not take section 8.  Section 8 usually is good for C grade areas. They can usually demand better than d grade but B grade means ability to get someone with 700 plus credit though it might not be as easy as A grade where you can just set up 1 open house and get them.  If you can get someone with 700 plus credit and 5x or 6x monthly  income over rent it should be smooth.  Id rather get that sort of person at 1400 then section 8 at 1500.  you can deny on credit btw to reject section 8.  There are a few places were woke stupidity has said you can't screen on credit.  SC is not 1 of them.  I'm sure landlord are really respecting that where its happening.  Lol. 


 Yeah definitely. I would say it's definitely a B- area, if maybe a C+. I'm thankful for everyones input here. I am going to move away from the Section 9 stuff and try to do a better job with finding a normal tenant. Take your suggestions and price down just slightly, but manage my advertising better hopefully. Thank you so much!

Post: Potential Section 8 tenant, unsure of how to proceed on 1st deal

Hannah WhitePosted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Greenville, SC
  • Posts 7
  • Votes 6
Quote from @Bob Stevens:
Quote from @Hannah White:

@Kevin Sobilo, @Bob Stevens, @Scott Crowley, @Malkia Ra

Thank you for all of your responses. My real estate agent did some market comps for my area and $1,500 was well within the fair market value of properties of the same type. The HUD fair market rent for my area on the federal website is around $1,200. I have been getting a lot of interest in the property, getting several dozens of inquiries about it across many platforms which I feel is good. I try to weed out tenants who won't meet income requirements immediately with my first response being that they must make 3x the monthly rent and pass a credit/background check. About 75% of people don't respond to that or say thanks for your time, which I expected.

Of the 25% that want to move forward, I do showings and they express real interest and then never fill out the application or ghost me. I've only received 3 completed applications, 2 of which had horrible credit history and then the 1 I approved that has the section 8 voucher. I do still have the property listed and am still getting inquiries, but have been holding since we were moving forward with this particular tenant. 

I believe my property is a class B house in a class B neighborhood. I'm in Upstate SC. House is a couple of miles from a local university, within 20 miles of Clemson University and close to many jobs and general amenities such as good restaurants, grocery stores, etc. I had professional pictures taken of the house and am including a washer/dryer with the property.

The reason I have hesitated to do property management is because this is my first deal and I'm trying to save capital to increase profits. My goal is to save every penny I make from this until I can purchase the next property, hopefully within a year or so. Then keep doing that for a few years until it can be really profitable. I had planned to utilize PM once I acquire more properties.

But yes the section 8 thing has me in a predicament. The tenant can afford the $1,500 per month rent based on the employment and income verification that I received with her application. The housing authority is telling me that she cannot based on their standard and that $1,211 is the most they can do with me on a lease agreement with the option to increase the rent after a year. So I am getting conflicting information and have wasted almost 2 weeks with the housing authority trying to get this through. They only told me this today. When I sent in the tenancy approval paperwork to them, it was clearly stated that my rent is $1,500/mo and I feel they should have let me know this was an issue sooner. I apologize for this being so long and thank you all for your time.

 Odd sec 8 pays more in my market. Also I understand you want to try and maximize your returns; but 100 bux a month is not going to affect it, if it does its not a good deal. You are not ready to go on your own. It can be very costly if you do not understand how it works. HIRE a PM co, learn then if you want fire them in 6 months or a year.  I have seen many ( here on BP) get crushed. They do not know how to evict, overpaying for repairs and more. Look you already wasted two weeks; time is money.  So how much will it cost if you do not do things correctly and sec8 abates your rent? Do you know what repairs are needed PRIOR to inspections? Do you know how difficult the inspectors can be? I have done 100s and 100s and 100s  of move ins withe Sec 8, and they still fail us for a door rubbing on the carpet, or those .50 little plastic caps that cover the screws that hold down the toilet.  HIRE a PM co, I have no dog in this, I am just trying to help. Oh, see if your area has a program called EDEN, we use them as well. They pay even more then sec 8 and they do inspections in a week and when it fails, they will come back out fast, unlike sec 8 , EDEN is much easier to work with, BUT SCREEN well. See your PM co would have known this (or they should) and it would be rented by now :) 

BTW I live in SC, HOWEVER I am a Gamecocks fan, so I can FINALLY say , sorry about Clemsons loss, well not really ,  LOL

All the best 


 Thank you for your response! I am a Gamecock fan to and have been so excited all week about the win and Beamer ball for our team! I will definitely look into Eden. I'm thinking I'm going to refocus and not work with Section 8 as this seems to be a major hassle that I'm not prepared for yet. 

Post: Potential Section 8 tenant, unsure of how to proceed on 1st deal

Hannah WhitePosted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Greenville, SC
  • Posts 7
  • Votes 6

@Kevin Sobilo, @Bob Stevens, @Scott Crowley, @Malkia Ra

Thank you for all of your responses. My real estate agent did some market comps for my area and $1,500 was well within the fair market value of properties of the same type. The HUD fair market rent for my area on the federal website is around $1,200. I have been getting a lot of interest in the property, getting several dozens of inquiries about it across many platforms which I feel is good. I try to weed out tenants who won't meet income requirements immediately with my first response being that they must make 3x the monthly rent and pass a credit/background check. About 75% of people don't respond to that or say thanks for your time, which I expected.

Of the 25% that want to move forward, I do showings and they express real interest and then never fill out the application or ghost me. I've only received 3 completed applications, 2 of which had horrible credit history and then the 1 I approved that has the section 8 voucher. I do still have the property listed and am still getting inquiries, but have been holding since we were moving forward with this particular tenant. 

I believe my property is a class B house in a class B neighborhood. I'm in Upstate SC. House is a couple of miles from a local university, within 20 miles of Clemson University and close to many jobs and general amenities such as good restaurants, grocery stores, etc. I had professional pictures taken of the house and am including a washer/dryer with the property.

The reason I have hesitated to do property management is because this is my first deal and I'm trying to save capital to increase profits. My goal is to save every penny I make from this until I can purchase the next property, hopefully within a year or so. Then keep doing that for a few years until it can be really profitable. I had planned to utilize PM once I acquire more properties.

But yes the section 8 thing has me in a predicament. The tenant can afford the $1,500 per month rent based on the employment and income verification that I received with her application. The housing authority is telling me that she cannot based on their standard and that $1,211 is the most they can do with me on a lease agreement with the option to increase the rent after a year. So I am getting conflicting information and have wasted almost 2 weeks with the housing authority trying to get this through. They only told me this today. When I sent in the tenancy approval paperwork to them, it was clearly stated that my rent is $1,500/mo and I feel they should have let me know this was an issue sooner. I apologize for this being so long and thank you all for your time.

Post: Potential Section 8 tenant, unsure of how to proceed on 1st deal

Hannah WhitePosted
  • New to Real Estate
  • Greenville, SC
  • Posts 7
  • Votes 6

Good morning BP,

This is my first post and I will try to be concise. I bought my first SFH a couple months ago with intention of doing long term rentals. I have been doing showings/marketing for over a month and gotten only a handful of actual applications. I have no experience with Section 8. But I have an applicant that I approved that has housing vouchers. My current rent price is set at $1,500/mo for a 3b/2ba with garage. The tenants vouchers are for $1,211/mo. I was under the assumption that the housing authority pays the voucher amount and the tenant covers the rest to meet the $1,500 rent price. The HA representative told me today the the $1,211 is the governments portion and the tenants portion combined.


The tenant has enough income to pay her amount of the voucher and the extra needed for my listed rent price, plus other living expenses, decent credit score and good background check. My concern is this: essentially the tenant would be paying me under the table for the remaining rent not covered by the voucher. I had intended to sign a separate contract from the HA lease with the tenant. This is probably a horrible idea, but since I have no landlording experience whatsoever I am in need of some direction please. I believe my judgement may be clouded by the fact that I have had zero decent quality tenants apply in over a month and have had trouble filling the vacancy. I am also concerned that I could get into legal trouble with the FHA for getting more rent from the tenant than would be contracted. But I have not been able to find any information of a situation like this online.


Can anyone please help me out? And let me know if I can clarify any information I may have forgot to include. Thank you!