@Kevin Sobilo, @Bob Stevens, @Scott Crowley, @Malkia Ra
Thank you for all of your responses. My real estate agent did some market comps for my area and $1,500 was well within the fair market value of properties of the same type. The HUD fair market rent for my area on the federal website is around $1,200. I have been getting a lot of interest in the property, getting several dozens of inquiries about it across many platforms which I feel is good. I try to weed out tenants who won't meet income requirements immediately with my first response being that they must make 3x the monthly rent and pass a credit/background check. About 75% of people don't respond to that or say thanks for your time, which I expected.
Of the 25% that want to move forward, I do showings and they express real interest and then never fill out the application or ghost me. I've only received 3 completed applications, 2 of which had horrible credit history and then the 1 I approved that has the section 8 voucher. I do still have the property listed and am still getting inquiries, but have been holding since we were moving forward with this particular tenant.
I believe my property is a class B house in a class B neighborhood. I'm in Upstate SC. House is a couple of miles from a local university, within 20 miles of Clemson University and close to many jobs and general amenities such as good restaurants, grocery stores, etc. I had professional pictures taken of the house and am including a washer/dryer with the property.
The reason I have hesitated to do property management is because this is my first deal and I'm trying to save capital to increase profits. My goal is to save every penny I make from this until I can purchase the next property, hopefully within a year or so. Then keep doing that for a few years until it can be really profitable. I had planned to utilize PM once I acquire more properties.
But yes the section 8 thing has me in a predicament. The tenant can afford the $1,500 per month rent based on the employment and income verification that I received with her application. The housing authority is telling me that she cannot based on their standard and that $1,211 is the most they can do with me on a lease agreement with the option to increase the rent after a year. So I am getting conflicting information and have wasted almost 2 weeks with the housing authority trying to get this through. They only told me this today. When I sent in the tenancy approval paperwork to them, it was clearly stated that my rent is $1,500/mo and I feel they should have let me know this was an issue sooner. I apologize for this being so long and thank you all for your time.