Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Anthony Halstead

Anthony Halstead has started 4 posts and replied 70 times.

Post: Still Waiting On Hyperinflation...

Anthony HalsteadPosted
  • Developer
  • Posts 72
  • Votes 31

Bryan, the more printing, the more inflation, and the more debt which is not payable... the more people/investors will realize that the dollar/euro are not stores of wealth, and when that happens, people will sell them for whatever they perceive as needing. It has happened before many times, and it will happen again. I am not saying it is going to happen, but that is how it happens. When the debt and inflation become too large, confidence suffers and then you get hyperinflation. It does not need to go the way of zimbabwe or Weimer Germany, but I guess 20-30% per year is close enough to hyperinflation for me and I would be getting out of cash as fast as it was earned as would many others I suspect. Even at 5-10% inflation, I am not planning to have much of my wealth in cash, taxes reduce that enough that I do not need inflation taking a bite as well...

And it does not need to be a complete loss in confidence, just loosing enough confidence that you exchange it for something else. It can still serve as a medium of exchange, just a rapidly depreciating one. See Paul Krugman's babysitter analogy for a popular idea of how to make people spend their money by depreciating the value of it... funny thing is that they do not need to print the depreciation or expiration on the dollar when there is high inflation, most people will spend it anyways, thus increasing the velocity of money...

Wise, income producing debt without too much leverage is my personal way to be prepared for this... and as stated above, when the high inflation comes, pull equity out of the property and buy. One caveat is that cash is king, so you need to have some cash for the deals if a situation develops that banks are not lending but deals abound.

Just my thoughts.

Tony.

Post: Real Estate Investing Math Applications

Anthony HalsteadPosted
  • Developer
  • Posts 72
  • Votes 31

#2. 222.13 annually?

Post: Still Waiting On Hyperinflation...

Anthony HalsteadPosted
  • Developer
  • Posts 72
  • Votes 31

Bryan, read the article you reference: Why the Pessimists Are Wrong About Inflation.

Food prices, gasoline, health insurance costs and college tuition are already rising much faster than the official inflation rate. But consider too that appliances, cell phones, computers, consumer electronics, cars, furniture and (ahem) home prices are coming decidedly down.

This fits my theory that things which we need will get more expensive, things financed on debt or not necessary will get cheaper. I think this is due to a tightness of money, people do not have as much money left over to spend on those discretionary items, and the debt items cannot be paid (debt is paying tomorrow for today's item, thus robbing tomorrow's savings and earnings and thus investment) so the demand for those is going down, thus the price goes down.

When money is easy, demand is high, when money is tight, demand decreases.

Tony.

Post: Still Waiting On Hyperinflation...

Anthony HalsteadPosted
  • Developer
  • Posts 72
  • Votes 31

Quick math quiz (with answer): If inflation is ONLY 3% per year, after ten years what will be the purchasing power of $10,000?

Answer: $7,374.24. So you lost $2,625.76 through inflation. That is why inflation is called the stealth tax, or hidden tax, and is why you do not feel so wealthy even though you may earn more.

Price go up (price inflation) which steals (stealth tax) your money. That is inflation at work. And you can see what a modest 3% per year does. At 4%, you are left with $6648, at just 5% inflation per year for ten years your 10,000 is down to only $5,987.

If we start to hit the 10% rates, you are left with $3,486.79... I think that that was what happened in the 70's. So if you have cash, you will pay.

Check the math please.

Tony

Post: Still Waiting On Hyperinflation...

Anthony HalsteadPosted
  • Developer
  • Posts 72
  • Votes 31

@Jim, austerity is already here. Look at the prices, that is inflation. That is sometimes called the hidden tax, or stealth tax. They print money, prices go up, you pay. Watch the following interview:

http://www.zerohedge.com/article/marc-faber-everything-going-only-federal-reserve-there-no-inflation

There is a pretty good discussion (at least Marc discusses some pretty good ideas) and in there Marc Faber discusses his theory for what is going on. He is a very smart guy, so smart he is usally too early (called tech bubble in 97-98, called housing in 2002-2003), and I respect his ideas/advice.

Austerity is here, do you have more or less cash than you used to? That is what inflation does to the average person; takes their money without them realizing it.

Couple good educational articles:

http://www.takelifeback.com/hegawid/

and

http://www.takelifeback.com/moltz/

Though comics, that makes the topic understandable for the average person, and they do a good job of explaining the economy, innovation and job growth, inflation,etc.

A further step if you really want to actually understand:

http://www.hacer.org/pdf/Hazlitt00.pdf

After reading those three I think you can see what is going on and also see what is going to happen. The stories are the same, you just have to figure out what page we are on...

Tony.

Post: Still Waiting On Hyperinflation...

Anthony HalsteadPosted
  • Developer
  • Posts 72
  • Votes 31

Hyperinflation is different than inflation. If you take the original defination of inflation, (and as currently used by Austrian School Economists) you track inflation as an increase in the money supply, and price increases (commonly referred to as inflation today) are the effect of the money printing. So first defining which inflation, monetary inflation, or price inflation you are talking about is required.

There is no doubt that money supply has been inflated recently. The fed publishes figures and you can see what is going on. Somewhat more difficult to see is price inflation. The CPI is the most common but is skewed to make the govt look good. Looking at prices of common goods one can see price inflation; see gasoline, health care, college tuition, food, silver, oil, etc. The basic commodities are shooting up, which means that all derivative products are also getting more expensive. One way that producers are trying to mask this is by making packages smaller; a "green" package, "effeciency" packages, etc. The net result is maybe only a 10% increase in price, but when you couple that with the 15-20 decrease in product per package, you get 30-40% inflation. And this is happening more and more in the last year or two.

So that was inflation (the two types). Hyperinflation, on the other hand, is a loss in confidence in the currency being printed. It is not like in monopoly, when the more money you get, the more prices go up (remember, at first you dont have much money, so deals are cheap, but as the game progresses and everyone has tons of cash, the bids get higher and higher, hmm, sounds like the housing bubble), but rather that people realise that there is inflation, and that the currency is not a store of value, and they go out to spend (get rid of it, ie exchange it for something of value) it before it is worth less. So hyperinflation is when people do not trust their money anymore and want to buy stuff before the price goes up (ie the value of the paper money declines further).

So hyperinflation is a rare event, but not as rare, nor as impossible as people would like to believe. Argentina is now experiencing inflation in the area of 30% per year, this is very soon going to be hyperinflation if history has any rhyme to it.

The main complication today IMO with the hyperinflation/deflation/inflation debates is that there was such a huge increase in debt (learn how money is issued from banks, they can loan (create, print) 10x the money they have on deposit) money in the last couple bubbles that when the bubbles collapse the debt money disappears, this is monetary deflation (not price deflation) but means that there is less "wealth" on paper, and real losses for many. And debt is spending today what we need to tomorrow pay for, and if the earnings and savings are not there to pay, then money is tight. So the money printing, which is going to the banks to make up for that 10x debt money they created which is evaporating, and not going to the unemployed, underwater, etc, is not having such a big effect on prices yet... But money chases yield. Not going to housing yet, still such debt, and bankers not gonna buy their own shadow inventory, so it goes to stock markets and commodities. That is why the stock market has held up so well, and why commodities are so highly priced. And that is why food, clothes, etc are showing price inflation as well.

I do not see hyperinflation (remember, this a loss in confidence in the currency) happening yet; the US is still the largest producer of food in the world, still dominant in most areas, still no clear alternative (other than gold, etc) so most will cling to the hope that the US will be a safe haven. And remember, most people would rather believe the easy lie than face the hard truth, so they will cling to what has been, rather than look at the facts and accept what is coming.

I think that the situation is unsustainable, but for hyperinflation to come, people need to realize that, accept that, and react accordingly. I do not see the realization on a large scale yet; most would rather believe the easy lie perpetuated by politicians and media and bankers and real estate pros (NAR statistics, sorry for offending any straight shooting real estate people, but so many are clueless and lie) who push housing as the best investment, retirement/'investment managers, etc. They do not yet want to think that something is wrong and take the next step to figure out what and why, which would lead to what to do. When that happens (assuming that the economy and spending continue in this same direction, major deficits, high rate of unemployment, debt overhangs, etc) then you can worry about "hyperinflation", but for now it will be inflation, or stagflation, re the 70's. And look what happened then; gold, oil, etc shot up. Interest rates shot up. Inflation shot up. And then the economy took off, after a long period. Will that happen again this time? who knows, history does not repeat, but is rhymes. Some things are different this time; high debt, low savings, cannot really lower taxes more due to already insane deficit, wars, high oil, lots of jobs have been offshored and not coming back, it is a global economy now, not a US economy, so competion is worldwide for jobs, so many may not come back soon, at least as they were.

My outlook? Things which you "need", ie oil, clothes, food, healthcare, etc, will continue to get more expensive in the near term. Things which were financed/bought with debt will continue to get cheaper in the near term, ie housing, cars, boats, vacation cabins, toys, etc. People have to get rid of the debt items (cant pay for them) and pay for the things they need. And with higher unemployment, and tighter credit (banks not giving money to customers, putting it to "pay off bad debt", investing it in stocks, commodities,etc, remember money chases yield and the bankers have been burnt on housing and consumers, wonder why your HELOC which was unused was cancelled even tho you have 800 credit?), financing is not as big an option as it was.

So what about real estate? No crystal ball, I threw it away a long time ago... but I think that having a part of net worth in real estate or income producing assets is worthwhile. betting on appreciation will be a losing game for a while IMO, but if you can cashflow a decent amount and hang on to what you have even if prices drop another 30% (it can happen...) then you will be positioned well if/when prices increase in the future (10-15 years from now). remember, bottoms take time, recoveries are not instantaneous and even with the money pumping by the fed, this will take a while. but being in place, not too high leverage, and cashflowing allows you to build equity, gain experience, and when the prices start to rise, pull the equity out of your houses and start to buy. Not your own money at that point because renters have paid it.

Those are my thoughts, lol, just lookint that this was "quick reply"

Tony.

Thanks for the extensive, quick reply Bill, do you ever sleep?

Do you have any thoughts specifically on this article:
http://www.oftwominds.com/blogapril11/new-mtg-rules4-11.html

Tony

One more thing, what will this do to the note industry? Private notes will get more expensive/more difficult/less supply?

Anyone see this happening, or can anyone explain why it will not happen?

Marc, Bill, I especially value your extensive wisdom.

Thanks,

Tony.

Just want to add to this post. Here is an article talking about more regs to "make it more fair for the poor consumer".

http://www.oftwominds.com/blogapril11/new-mtg-rules4-11.html

When you combine that with Frank-Dodd and SAFE, pretty much makes a mess. So many regs to keep up with, lots of fees going to licensing and attorny and now mortgage originator... Where does it end?

Or is it just BS? If you are buying on the cheap, fixing, and then selling with owner financing (houses and MHs), do you need to worry about these? Should you run every deal through a licensed originator, and get other licenses yourself?

Tony.

Post: Joint Venture Questions

Anthony HalsteadPosted
  • Developer
  • Posts 72
  • Votes 31

Bryan, really check on that. If someone is not activelly contributing to the decisions and management, you may be in violation, but get a second opinion (from qualified, experienced legal council).

Tony.

And I think the SEC does not care if you do not know, they will nail you for all past instances as well if you get in trouble, best find out and get it clarified, find a case precedent if possible.