Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: George S.

George S. has started 5 posts and replied 20 times.

Looking for a commercial property management company in the Akron area, 18K sq foot office building.  

If the community can provide any recommendations, it would be greatly appreciated.  

Thank you! George 

Thank you both Hai and Micheal for your advice. I spoke to my real estate attorney this afternoon and was not very thrilled with the idea either, and is not sure if we can structure the LLC to allow me as the principal owner to force the PM company to sell me their equity in the property 5 yrs down the line if they are underperforming on the PM end.

To be honest I felt reassured at the idea that they have some skin in the game, and not only manage the property but be a proxy for me in front of the tenants when collecting and making financial decisions especially with repairs.  

I also spoke to a very well known realtor in the area this afternoon asking for some advice in regards to the same dilemma, and basically advised me not to take on any partners, but find a independent property management company or even better a person living in the park.  

I later spoke to the seller, who also owns 2000 other properties (or so the rumor goes) in the area, and they actually advised me to go with scenario #1 because they know the PM team and the work they do, both thorough and frugal.  

Just wanted to provide an update.  Thank you again! GS 

Hey BP community. I have a question and would like the communities thoughts on it.

I am in contract with a new partner on a mobile home, both as passive investors. I am planning on moving out of state and being an absentee owner while the other owner is staying put. The park has 40 homes, gross rent 110-140K yearly.

This is going to be the partners 3rd mobile home park purchase and is wanting to bring the property management company who is currently both managing and part owners on one of the parters other parks. The property management team consists of two late middle aged people that have been doing this full time for the past 3-4 yrs.

Two scenarios have developed
1. The management company wants 10% ownership in the company, which is loaned by us over 10 yrs, in addition to the 9% property management fee.

2. My realtor, who I completely trust, has approached me and said he is willing to manage the property on the side for 20% ownership, loaned over 10 yrs and 10% management fee. The realtor already is managing a 10 mobile park home that he owns on the side.

Questions

1. If I do scenario #1, how do I structure the LLC so that if the property manager is underperforming, or I learn about them taking money on the side, would I be able to boot them and return their equity, or do they have the legal right to continue and have 10% ownership as long as they are making their monthly loan repayment to me.

2. Do scenario #2, that way my business circle meets the criteria of only going into business with someone you trust, however in this scenario, it comes at the cost of me taking on more risk on the investment and possibly severing a fruitful relationship with a partner or partners.

Justing looking for a bit of wisdom, please provide any that may help. Thank you!! George.

Thank you Peter.  You know I have not thought about that third scenario, I suppose I maybe placing too much emphasis on a property manager having some skin in the game.  

Hey BP community. I have a question and would like the communities thoughts on it. 

I am in contract with a new partner on a mobile home, both as passive investors.  I am planning on moving out of state and being an absentee owner while the other owner is staying put.  The park has 40 homes, gross rent 110-140K yearly.  

This is going to be the partners 3rd mobile home park purchase and is wanting to bring the property management company who is currently both managing and part owners on one of the parters other parks.  The property management team consists of two late middle aged people that have been doing this full time for the past 3-4 yrs.  

Two scenarios have developed
1.  The management company wants 10% ownership in the company, which is loaned by us over 10 yrs, in addition to the 9% property management fee.  

2. My realtor, who I completely trust, has approached me and said he is willing to manage the property on the side for 20% ownership, loaned over 10 yrs and 10% management fee.  The realtor already is managing a 10 mobile park home that he owns on the side. 

Questions

1. If I do scenario #1, how do I structure the LLC so that if the property manager is underperforming, or I learn about them taking money on the side, would I be able to boot them and return their equity, or do they have the legal right to continue and have 10% ownership as long as they are making their monthly loan repayment to me.  

2. Do scenario #2, that way my business circle meets the criteria of only going into business with someone you trust, however in this scenario, it comes at the cost of me taking on more risk on the investment and possibly severing a fruitful relationship with a partner or partners.   

Justing looking for a bit of wisdom, please provide any that may help.  Thank you!! George.

Originally posted by @Matthew Ryan:

@George S. - I own a Triple Net Industrial and I will say a few things that I don't believe have been covered yet:

(1) Anything NNN in Industrial or Retail you have to be a sector expert for the prospective tenants. You have to KNOW their business. SWOT. I just came back from an investor summit where every syndicator who does retail NNN (including small markets you're looking at) made an extremely compelling case for the strength in retail vs. what the news is covering. They're having a hay day because everyone thinks the market is collapsing and it's creating massive buying opportunities. They know their tenant as well as anyone. I think there's incredible opportunity for triple net from a cash flow (and overall return) perspective however I think it takes a very experienced sponsor or investor to do them well and with extremely conservative underwriting standards.

(2) ST cash flows are more supportive than some traditional MF and due to the LT nature of the leases, you don't always have the turn and burn you get in MF. What I mean is MF investors typically like to get in and get out. That creates capital events, paperwork, hopefully profits but then taxes if you don't complete an exchange. 

(3) I second the cap rate comments (way too low) and I'd second shopping other syndicators or fund managers and get a better handle of the industry at large. 

Best of luck to you. 

 Thank you Ryan for taking time out of your day to write these insightful comments.  

Originally posted by @Matthew Ryan:

@George S. - I own a Triple Net Industrial and I will say a few things that I don't believe have been covered yet:

(1) Anything NNN in Industrial or Retail you have to be a sector expert for the prospective tenants. You have to KNOW their business. SWOT. I just came back from an investor summit where every syndicator who does retail NNN (including small markets you're looking at) made an extremely compelling case for the strength in retail vs. what the news is covering. They're having a hay day because everyone thinks the market is collapsing and it's creating massive buying opportunities. They know their tenant as well as anyone. I think there's incredible opportunity for triple net from a cash flow (and overall return) perspective however I think it takes a very experienced sponsor or investor to do them well and with extremely conservative underwriting standards.

(2) ST cash flows are more supportive than some traditional MF and due to the LT nature of the leases, you don't always have the turn and burn you get in MF. What I mean is MF investors typically like to get in and get out. That creates capital events, paperwork, hopefully profits but then taxes if you don't complete an exchange. 

(3) I second the cap rate comments (way too low) and I'd second shopping other syndicators or fund managers and get a better handle of the industry at large. 

Best of luck to you. 

Originally posted by @Ian Ippolito:

@George S. 

I like triple net lease properties and have them in my portfolio. However, as a conservative investor I would not be comfortable with holding just one (or even two), because if one of them goes dark it will have a substantial hit on your returns (and may possibly negative if you have retenant). Personally I like to invest in the asset class through a diversified fund. There is one that I am invested in that markets under 506b so they cannot publicly advertise. But the portfolio has hundreds of properties across the US, the principals have full real estate cycle experience in the asset class, and it's the only private REIT that I know of that has an investment grade rating. If you want more info on them, PM me.

Thank you for your advice, it is greatly appreciated.  I definitely feel more comfortable when being diversified, will send a PM shortly to obtain more info.  Thanks!!

Originally posted by @Joel Owens:

George I believe you have e-mailed me and I sent a response back. I have certain requirements before I work with an investor and take them on as a client.

I can tell you in a nutshell the difference between what I do which is not typical in the industry and what the commercial real estate industry does in general.

Unless an investor is in the trenches day to day they do not know how things operate. Let me pull back the curtain some.

Typical brokerage model is they are LISTERS. They list everything under the sun whether that is a good,bad, or crappy property. They set up teams of brokers/agents. So if commission was 100,000 to the listing side on a transaction 50k generally goes to the brokerage then the other 50k is split among usually 3 people on the team. Top person gets maybe 25,000 and bottom person 8,000.

Conversley when I close a deal representing a buyer exclusively and it is my company I keep it all. Those listing agents have to run really hard on that hamster wheel 4 to 8 deals to equal my ONE transaction. This is why listing brokers typically send a property and say (what do you think?) They really do not have time for anything else as they represent the sellers. Most want a REIT, fund, or syndicate to buy because these seasoned buyers already have their own process to purchase. The listing broker says here is the property go under contract and do your thing. I will check back in 3 to 4 weeks to see if it closes or falls out etc.

The commercial buyer broker specialist has a whole network for that buyer of retail property management companies, 1031 exchange companies, vendors for reports (environmental phase one, appraisal, property condition report, ALTA level one survey), capital markets lenders, commercial retail attorneys, proprietary on and off market properties nationally.

When  a buyer wants a commercial broker to evaluate properties using their knowledge for guidance they have to make an exclusive commitment to that broker.

Some of my friends run listing brokerages and have meetings every week with junior agents and then do tons of listings at reduced commissions to try to make it up on volume. Head person at the company might be pulling in 800k to 1 million a year or so after splits and expenses.

I choose to work on the buyer side as I enjoy that more. Contrary to what some might believe listing brokers do not really want to deal with buyers. They do not have time to hold their hand and give them all this intensive information and help. They make so little per deal they do not have time for that. That is why the listing brokerages love someone like me. They know I have a reputation and system for helping the buyers and they only have to interact with me which makes their life easier and they know I have already qualified the buyer  and they want to know I work with the buyer exclusively.

Nothing sends off FLAKE signals to a listing brokerage or owner directly faster than hearing a buyer is all over the place who they are working with and what type of asset they are buying. The brokers want a buyer with FOCUS, CLARITY, COMMITMENT.  

Thank you for the very thorough & insightful response!

Being a realtor is a very demanding job, and I believe they deserve every dollar that they make.  

Concerning the last paragraph 

'Nothing sends off FLAKE signals to a listing brokerage or owner directly faster than hearing a buyer is all over the place who they are working with and what type of asset they are buying. The brokers want a buyer with FOCUS, CLARITY, COMMITMENT'

As a new potential investor I guess what I was hoping was something more out of the commercial realtors.  You would think that with such so much money being made and exchanged daily with commercial real estate that they could provide me with some hard numbers and what they mean, so that I can make an informed decision and say 'this property has good potential lets be aggressive.'  If the commercial broker is not able to provide me with the info, then at the minimum point me in the direction that I can find it; or maybe I am wrong, but there HAS to be some science (statistics) driving these decisions.  I do not expect neither do I want to be proficient in REI, but I do want to make an informed decision and I need information to do that.  

Just sent a reply email, thanks for your thoughts! 

Originally posted by @Joel Owens:

George I believe you have e-mailed me and I sent a response back. I have certain requirements before I work with an investor and take them on as a client.

I can tell you in a nutshell the difference between what I do which is not typical in the industry and what the commercial real estate industry does in general.

Unless an investor is in the trenches day to day they do not know how things operate. Let me pull back the curtain some.

Typical brokerage model is they are LISTERS. They list everything under the sun whether that is a good,bad, or crappy property. They set up teams of brokers/agents. So if commission was 100,000 to the listing side on a transaction 50k generally goes to the brokerage then the other 50k is split among usually 3 people on the team. Top person gets maybe 25,000 and bottom person 8,000.

Conversley when I close a deal representing a buyer exclusively and it is my company I keep it all. Those listing agents have to run really hard on that hamster wheel 4 to 8 deals to equal my ONE transaction. This is why listing brokers typically send a property and say (what do you think?) They really do not have time for anything else as they represent the sellers. Most want a REIT, fund, or syndicate to buy because these seasoned buyers already have their own process to purchase. The listing broker says here is the property go under contract and do your thing. I will check back in 3 to 4 weeks to see if it closes or falls out etc.

The commercial buyer broker specialist has a whole network for that buyer of retail property management companies, 1031 exchange companies, vendors for reports (environmental phase one, appraisal, property condition report, ALTA level one survey), capital markets lenders, commercial retail attorneys, proprietary on and off market properties nationally.

When  a buyer wants a commercial broker to evaluate properties using their knowledge for guidance they have to make an exclusive commitment to that broker.

Some of my friends run listing brokerages and have meetings every week with junior agents and then do tons of listings at reduced commissions to try to make it up on volume. Head person at the company might be pulling in 800k to 1 million a year or so after splits and expenses.

I choose to work on the buyer side as I enjoy that more. Contrary to what some might believe listing brokers do not really want to deal with buyers. They do not have time to hold their hand and give them all this intensive information and help. They make so little per deal they do not have time for that. That is why the listing brokerages love someone like me. They know I have a reputation and system for helping the buyers and they only have to interact with me which makes their life easier and they know I have already qualified the buyer  and they want to know I work with the buyer exclusively.

Nothing sends off FLAKE signals to a listing brokerage or owner directly faster than hearing a buyer is all over the place who they are working with and what type of asset they are buying. The brokers want a buyer with FOCUS, CLARITY, COMMITTMENT.