@Eric DeVito
Sounds like you've made the decision to invest outside of Brooklyn because you feel you're priced out of your own backyard. I felt the same way about my area (SoCal) and decided to invest out of state. That was three years ago. Since then, I've made one SFH work with consistent cash flow, and then another, and now I'm working on my third SFH, and will hopefully pick up another by year's end. Maybe even a duplex/ triplex. You need a plan of attack. Here's what worked for me:
a) Getting over the emotional/ mental hurdle of being an out-of-state investor. Sounds like a weird thing for some folks, but for me, there were lots of fears and scary "what-ifs" that immobilized me, especially as a newbie. How did I get over this? Education. That is to say:
b) I made a list of everything that I didn't understand and things that I feared could contribute to my downside as an investor. The lovely folks at BP have listed some of these things here -- everything from slimy PMs to Mother Nature to investing on the wrong block.
c) I gave myself a reasonable timeline to research all the things on my list of scary/confusing things (I read books, the internet, forums, called realtors, friends, etc.)
d) After my research deadline passed, I pulled the trigger by visiting the area for a weekend (I made arrangements to be hosted/shown around by a local wholesaler who had several properties I was interested in. I found him on the internet.). By the time I got on a plane to come back home, I'd signed a contract with him to pick up my first SFH! Since then, he's opened his REI network to me, and given me some solid advice.
e) Now I learn on the job. Some days I'm crushing it, and some days I'm getting my butt whooped. But I didn't jump in feet first, and I tried my best to minimize my ignorance and risk, so even though I learn lessons, they aren't backbreaking or life-threatening to my business. They're manageable and give me the kind of experience and stress that makes me grow.
Good luck, brother. Here's to your first cash-flowing property and future success.