hi @Troy Zsofka-
Exactly. You saved me a lot of typing!
If you really work it, I think i could break even on one. It'd be a lot of hustle filling it, it wouldn't scale, and you may end up a couple $k under at the end of the year.
For a couple $k, you could just rent for a week or two, and not spend all your time on vbro.
Most property managers will charge 25 to 40% of gross to rent & manage weekly rentals-- which kills your return (if you have one).
The most promising scenario was to rent it out for the winter and then weekly in the summer. If an annual rental would pay $1200/mo, a winter rental would pay $2400/mo & a summer 1200/wk. the winter rental is great b/c you can't rent weekly in the winter (it's mainly weekends, other than school vaca) and they would pay utilities, which is a huge expense in the oil-reliant north country.
But... You don't get to go skiing, which is why you bought the place!
I'll probably pick one up at one point, but the rental aspect will just try to keep it cash-neutral.