@Sean Mcintire
Buyer purchased 130+ condos in the complex on 10/23/18 for $9.49 million. I believe it averages out $70k per unit.
My wife and I received a copy of the condo termination agreement just today. It lists appraised value of the the 40+ condos that will be acquired from buyer. It also has an appraisal report for a condo that has the same floor plan as ours, but not our exact condo. The termination agreement lists that all 2 bed 2 bath, including ours, will be sold for $72k. Then it goes on to include language about how we can get our own appraisal and if buyer does not agree to the 2nd appraisal price then an arbitrator decides value that it will be sold at.
Buyer made us on offer about 6 weeks ago for $77k. We turned it down.
What's interesting, in reading the appraisal, the appraiser used the 10/23 transaction as the GREATEST WEIGHT to determine market value of the condo. This smells awfully fishy. Appraiser then lists two condos that are over 2.5 miles away as the 2nd and 3rd comp. He goes on to state that since they are so far away they are not an accurate gauge of value.
In looking at comps online myself, it show two condos in the same complex selling over the summer at 89k each.
Googling the appraisers name it shows that he had a AZ Board of Appraisal disciplinary action against him in 2013 that included 6 months probation with required mentorship and education. Language in the disciplinary hearing included one board member stating "the verbiage in the respondent's report made him think that it was biased toward investors, instead of reporting the market." Sounds like that might be the case again.
I'll look into filing a complaint against appraiser with AZ Board of Appraisal. I might be overreacting.
I hate that the other 40+ condo owners might use the value in his appraisal at the price they decide to sell at. It's as if the owners should be contacted to make sure they get their own appraisal done. I'll order and appraisal myself and let you know what happens.