@Chris H.
I'm actually doing a double closing on these locations
* Pueblo CO (~ 1 hr 50 mins from Denver) - Single Family
* Fort Morgan CO (~ 1 hr from Denver) - Duplex
I tend to look at online stats as well like population growth. Pueblo CO (including surrounding areas like Pueblo West ) has about 165K people , whereas Fort Morgan has about 12K people. After seeing Fort Morgan, it is a bit far, say there is a bubble, I do worry about the prices dropping substantially. Its a smaller town, so I need to research more, but what attracted me were the higher rental rates, and values are going up. I attribute this to the high demand in Denver and people looking for closer more affordable options.
Now I am a tech guy and I actually see Pueblo CO doing better (talking future) here, and here is why. I work remotely and have an excellent job. I believe people like me don't care where they live and want value for there money not higher prices. I've worked in Software/Engineering for a while, and many co-workers telecommute, and I believe this is a trend many people overlook. Pueblo was actually on the most affordable list of places to live (top 10 in the country), these kind of things get you noticed. I.e. I was looking at buying a $400K house in Pueblo West that would cost be $4 million in Denver. The reason I didn't move from my Denver home was my kids wanted to stay in school with there friends and we have all our family here.
As far as comparison, Fort Morgan is a small city, but closer in proximity to Denver, so I'm still trying to grasp the job market there (from my understanding there are mostly Mill jobs), and am taking a chance. Working with the Realtor/Property manager at this time it makes sense. However, looking at Pueblo, its a good size city, great internet (for people like me), low cost of living, they are expanding the Riverwalk the next 15 years, I wouldn't be surprised if we see a boom there. Not sure if I can mention this, but the marijuana industry is growing pretty fast there, so there are jobs and don't see this fading away anytime soon. :-)
I hope this helps in your endeavors, but that's what makes life fun. I don't know if I will be around next year given I'm a Round 4 cancer survivor but believe you keep living, and in REI, make choices that fit your goals and make sense to you.
Take care and best of luck,
Erich