@Luke H. It is pretty simple, be honest with yourself. I do not deduct for paint issues because you have to paint the unit anyway. Holes in the wall, deduct the cost to repair it. If your windows are old and are showing corrosion, that bill falls on you. All updating of fixtures falls on you. It’s been 7 years, don’t be cheap. Leaks under cabinet due to them not alerting you, charge them. Door knobs destroyed - it depends. If you are aware that your tile man did not do a good job which lead to split tile due to air bubbles under the tile that’s on you. If they were clumsy and chipped from dropping pots on it all the time. I would keep the whole deposit, they should have bought a mat. Take pictures of the damage. Walk slow, talk slow and point out everything. You made them sign a agreement, read it and follow your rules. If you did not include wording of a expiration date in your agreement then you should not add it on now.