@Diana Villalon
That's a tight deal. I'll answer some of your transactional questions as others have already provided feedback on the deal's merit, or lack thereof, as an investment.
So, i know the numbers don't really make a lot of sense, it's CA... :( but I"m wondering if it's worth putting in an offer to get my feet wet. I am low balling this one, as they are asking for almost 60k more than what I plan on offering.
Only you can determine if it's worth putting in an offer. I have clients that have purchased properties like this that barely break even or are negative CF. They do this for tax purposes, or because they don't care about cash flow. They believe in the long-term appreciation of CA and will buy, hold, and sell in the future for a profit (although it is never guaranteed).
Since this is an MLS deal, is it industry standard to negotiate the #'s with the seller to show him the numbers if it's on the MLS? Does anyone know? or would the agent just put in the offer and it comes back rejected? What do I do next?
In general, it doesn't matter whether it is MLS or non-MLS. You can provide the seller with comparable sales in the neighborhood. Don't share your particular financial calculations, but just the neighborhood comps (as single-family homes are valued based on comparable sales). A recent example is a property was listed for $675,000. The most recent comps in the last 90 days were going for $595,000. The seller was priced at comps from 6 months ago (which no longer apply in our current shifting market in the OC) so I negotiated the offer until $595,000 was accepted.
Pick a number. Provide the data that backs up your number, and stay strong on your "ceiling." Don't overpay just to get a deal unless you can justify the reasons for overpaying. AKA you know something that other's don't.
If the agent just puts in an offer and it gets rejected, you can negotiate further and "do the dance." If the seller doesn't respond, there's no interest. If there's no interest, they're not a real seller assuming your offer is fair according to comparable sales.