Hello BP Community,
I am new to landlording...just closed on my first property about a month ago, I'm in the southeastern PA market, it is a side by side duplex with a detached barn I rent out for storage. I inherited tenants on both sides of the duplex, the young couple on one side are about 3 months into a 1 year lease, and just sent me an email asking if they can break the lease and move out without paying a fee because they broke up (lease states that 50% of remaining term rent is the penalty). In my limited time knowing them, they appear to be good tenants that wouldn't give me problems. I'm sure there are plenty of more experienced investors on here who have received requests like this, do you always charge the full penalty the lease states? Are there any other factors I should consider as I decide how I want to respond/handle this?
P.S. I'm pretty confident that I'll be able to find a new tenant fairly quickly as the rent is around 10% below the median for comparable apartments in the area.