Natalie,
If you're still following this thread... I have lived in Tacoma since Jan 2016. I have a loft down in the financial district that I wish I could rent (rental cap) and I bought that back in June of 2016. Back then I thought by summer of 2017 I'd buy at least 2 more homes on Hilltop as they were around $125-150k each. Then, BOOM the market exploded. However, I don't think Tacoma is done yet.
UW has completely cleaned up the area down by the Swiss. The Brewery district is going through a massive reno as well to the tune of around $85 million I think. There is a GIANT project from a Chinese investment company on Jefferson and 21st that has hundreds of millions being invested into new SFH and retail. It's supposed to end up being similar to U Village.
a new high rise hotel is going in, in the same neighborhood, 25+ stories I believe (Hilton? I can't remember). The crane is already up and moving. Just up a few blocks from there another crane is putting in a large multifamily unit.
Hilltop is now more expensive by far than a year ago but the whole area is just now breaking ground on what we'll see over the next 5 years.
the east side of I5 only a mile or two as the crow flies is probably the next major neighborhood as there is a clean up project there a well.
Lastly, I believe the City has yet ANOTHER major clean up project going in right next to the mall that will consume a couple city blocks, create a new greenbelt and park, etc.
Ruston condos are selling for $1m+, and Proctor homes seem to start around $450k for the most part. There is one right now listed at $275 that would be a renovation project.
Anyways, best of luck to you. I've been watching Tacoma closely and am thinking of selling my loft so I can move my money into the next investment opportunity as well.