Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Donato Callahan

Donato Callahan has started 0 posts and replied 30 times.

Quote from @Jim Reynante:

After owning properties C/D neighborhoods with high crime statistics, I have experienced all of the things that go along with it: 1) High turnover rate; 2) Tenants that don't care for the property; 3) Little/No appreciation in home value; and 4) High Crime Rate (burglary, vandalism).

I am pretty tired of fixing broken windows, fixing broken doors/locks, and painting over graffiti. So I am looking for a change and a friend recommended Appleton, Wisconsin. So far, my research shows a good mix of demographics, population, incomes, AND the crime stats seem pretty low... lower than the national average.

Anyone investing in Appleton, WI and willing to share your thoughts/experience?   

Rent Growth don't lie in Appleton. This is what BrightInvestor has for 2 Bedrooms in the area. 

Quote from @Kay Nemen:

Hello everyone, my name is Kay. I'm new to investing. For the past few weeks, I have read many posts on BiggerPocket and learned so much about real estate. Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge and wisdom.

I'd like some advice on where to buy my next investment property using a DSCR loan. Right now, I'm house hacking - owning a three-family house in NYC and renting out the other two units. I want to buy an investment property out of state, and I'm considering Fort Worth, Phoenix, or Durham (NC). I plan on moving to the West Coast in the next 2-3 years, so considering that, I'm leaning towards Fort Worth or Phoenix only because my goal is to keep investing and buying properties, and it'd be easier if I lived nearby. What do you guys think about those places? I'm still very early in the buying process, so I'm open to all suggestions (I hear good things about Waco, Texas?)

Since this is my first time buying an investment property, I also wanted to get your feedback on my thought/research process and know if I'm heading in the right direction. This is what I have done so far in terms of the research on the area:

  1. - I looked up the rent on Rentometer and Zillow.
  2. - Did a quick city search on Areavibes. Looked at the job market and medium incomes. 
  3. - Looked at a few properties on Zillow, plugged the numbers into a DSCR calculator, and calculated the Cap rate.
  4. - Looked at the property tax. I learned that Texas has the highest property tax and Arizona has the lowest. Does this play a huge role in - buying investment properties?
  5. - My next step would be talking to lenders and realtors in all three cities to understand the current market better.

I'm also thinking it might be better to buy near hospitals/universities/tech companies/factories.

Am I missing anything, or is this typically the research one should do before buying an investment property?

Any help is appreciated!


 1. You're on the right track. Here is an appreciation map of Dallas and all the rules of thumb to follow when looking at a market. 


2. You might be out of luck if you want sub $350K in Dallas for a multifamily. I checked for you and in a high appreciating zip code there is only 1, off market 4 unit building for 178K and is likely in need of big repairs. 


3. Next things to look at crime, rent GROWTH, job market, population, and more. 

Let me know if you have questions and am happy to help. 

Quote from @Collin Mitchell:

I just bought four SFH outside San Antonio and the cash flow is minimal but bought them for appreciation and tax benefits.

Before I start marketing them I was consider a the mid-term rental option for one of them. 

I'm aware of AirDNA for AirBNB data but how do you do market research for mid-term rentals? 

Any help would be appreciated. 


 I got you bro. Here's an appreciation map of San Antonio. I love investing there and am under contract for 200 units in San Antonio right now. 


I use BrightInvestor to check local rents, crime stats, appreciation, renter population, rent growth, demographics, and more before buying a new property to make sure it aligns with my strategy. 

For MTRs, you want quiet, close proximity to hubs of traveling professionals, in an area that will see positive rent growth and appreciation. 

Post: Investing in US markets

Donato CallahanPosted
  • Posts 30
  • Votes 18
Quote from @Ty M.:

Hello looking to break into the US market in 2024. I have 1 unit in Toronto Canada and want to look for opportunities across the border. If any one has experience with this it would help (Mainly the lending process) Toronto is a vibrant city with lots of renters but it’s also expensive and renters have more rights than landlords. 


 What are you looking for? What type of property? What type of strategy? Regardless, make sure you buy in an area with...
- 10% Pop Growth over the past 10 Years
- 10% Job Growth over the past 10 Years
- Low Crime
- High Appreciation
- Manageable Entry Prices
- At least 30% Renter Population

Here's an example of all those rules of thumb with a crime map of Austin, TX. Use stuff like this and you'll have good markets and deals in no time. 

Post: Starting out Out of state investing

Donato CallahanPosted
  • Posts 30
  • Votes 18
Quote from @Chandler Alexander:

Does anyone have any tips on starting out for out of state investing. I found a property that seemed would work but a lender that I was referred to said they wouldn't be able to finance the loan because I lived out of state and they do not like doing something like this. Should I invest in my area? Problem is in my area the barrier to entry is so high it would take me so much longer. Any suggestions ?


 Chandler, the game of real estate must be played on a national scale. Some markets simply aren't going to have what you need, when you need it, at the price you need it. Others will. I buy across the US and am a big fan of OOS investing. 

For example, another guy here was looking into the Poconos region for an investment. I hop on BrightInvestor and see the area is appreciating like crazy. My market isn't growing like that. 

Or when I'm looking for areas in Austin, pull up a crime map and see where the warzones are.


There's plenty of information out there to help you find the best markets, best areas, and best deals to boost your out of state investing. You can also use those resources to PROVE to lenders with ACTUAL data what's happening in the market so they feel more comfortable. Just my 2 cents. 

Quote from @Danny J.:

I have a house that I've been using as an airbnb and had some questions about the market if anyone has some insight.

Thanks!

Edit: In particular, wanted to know about LTR potential and growth potential of the area in general. I'm not too familiar with the area and wanted to pick the brains of someone who knows more. Thanks!


 Danny, the appreciation in this areas is insane. I pulled up the area on BrightInvestor and this area has seen massive growth with very little pull back over the past year. I'm not even local and know enough to say this might be a solid place to hold a property for the long term.

BI has rent growth on it to so I'm sure you can get some answers on LTR potential here. 

For folks who are analyzing at least two deals a week, yes. They announced recently that their new version is adding MLS Access, Off-Market Properties, Wholesale leads for free to all thier elite users on the platform.

I look at a lot of multifamily in a few different markets so it's definitely worth it to me in the cost savings alone for all the different subscriptions I can cancel by just having this one. Biggest value is the time. I don't like jumping from site to site to site. 

Quote from @Thomas Murphy:

Hello everyone, for the past several months I have been passively educating myself on RE investing by listening to BP podcasts, reading through these forums, and analyzing some multifamily properties using the BP calculators. I am eager to begin building my portfolio with a focus on long term hold duplexes to start, but I want to make sure I am not getting too far ahead of myself too quickly. 

I currently live in New Hampshire where it seems like entry prices for 2-4 units is pretty high (that is, if there are more than a handful for sale at any given time) so I'm not sure that this would be a good market to start in. With that being said, my curiosity has since shifted to out of state investing courtesy of these forums and BP podcasts. I have a pretty good understanding of the importance of building your "Core 4", but admittedly the thought of investing in a property you likely won't see in person is a little daunting. 

I am currently looking in the Columbus, OH area and have also read some positive reviews about the Tulsa, OK area. 

As a new investor, what are some actionable things that I can do today to get me closer to acquiring my first property? Side note, I have already been pre-approved for 2-4 units in NH, but I imagine that number will vary depending on the market I choose. 

I appreciate any tips/tricks/recommendations and I appreciate your time responding to this post. 

Happy new year!


 Thomas, 

Out of State Investing is a honestly one of the best things we can do as investors to live where we like and profit how we like. I hear a lot of great things about Columbus and can tell you this...

Columbus is growing like a weed! Over 11% growth in the past decade and it is up and to the right. However, areas (in red) on this map show that certain spots in the city are actually losing population. If I were you, I'd do some more research into where the best spots are INSIDE Columbus, OH and also look at things like Crime, Income, Rents, and more. 

I use BrightInvestor to get that personally. 

Margaret, 

Both look like good markets - here's how I do it. 

Compare Population Growth, Job Growth, Income Growth, Rent Growth, Crime, Appreciation, Development, and available On & Off-Market deals. 

For example in Little Rock, AR...

In the zipcode 72205, income has grown almost 24% (I look for 10% minimum) and there are a few off-market, single family houses between $200K and $300K that are also absentee owner owned and high equity. 


This is a great way to cut through having to call a bunch of agents and get the answers you want immediately and without bias. Just my 2 cents and happy to help. 

Post: Investing in Clinton, SC

Donato CallahanPosted
  • Posts 30
  • Votes 18



Ethan, I checked out what BrightInvestor had. I found an on-market, 2Bed 1Bath that is an Absentee Owner with High Equity. Also, the market here has seen nearly 40% rent growth but been tumbling in the past few months. I'd recommend around $800/month for a 2B/1Bath based on this and would be very careful about over renovating properties here with rents that low.