Hello @Nick Leamon
I would certainly take a look at the advice from some of the seasoned investors here when it comes to reserves. You are 3.5 years from the PMI drop off and its almost guaranteed you will have an unexpected expense/possibly a large one, that eats into your cash by then. Are you putting all of the $245 into a reserve or savings? If not, I made that mistake on my first rental and I was fine like you are now, until the tenant of 2 years stopped paying, trashed the place the last two months and cost me thousands in repairs that lost all of the small profit I made each month over 2 years. Your rental is now at the mercy of the tenant and part of your plan appears to include the "hope" clause, i.e. - hope the tenant is perfect at maintaining the premises and hope that no major repairs or improvement come up in the next few years.
Also, I don't understand why you would forgo higher rent and ultimately cash in your pocket with a tactic of "below market value, but I'm more interested in quality, long term, low turnover tenets". My opinion is that a quality tenant is found by doing your due diligence on their income/work history/prior landlord references/credit checks, etc, having nothing to do with rent rate or number of people calling to see your rental. A great apartment at market rate will always rent!
I share these thoughts as someone who has learned a lot since my first rental and want to see you succeed, not making any oversights that can be costly and are in your immediate control.
Best of luck and keep us posted over time!