@Frank S., your side by side comparison makes it clear that you are claiming roughly equal ROI with the two investment strategies. That is flatly wrong. With zero trading, I'd have ended up with less than half what I made, using your own calculations and index fund as a guide. And it would all have been taxable.
So you are actually hyping the performance of index funds, which is very misleading. The hype factor is on you, not me.
Please reread my posts. I do not knock exploring multiple baskets. Explore all the baskets you want, just do thorough research before you actively invest. Otherwise stay in index funds or cash. And don't bet on diversification to save your money when the market goes in free-fall. Watch for signs of meltdown and move all your funds to the sidelines or at least set up proper stop losses.
Note that the current stock market is quite high, even by Case-Shiller PE charts. And the Fed has no significant strings left to pull if the market takes a dive. Rates are already close to zero.