For those invested in the conversation, here's an update:
1) Tenant's with unlawful weapons are moving out with a quit notice.
2) Other tenant who does not feel safe in the building is still planning on moving on (other circumstances playing in on the decision). PM's handling that transition and how she will exit her lease.
3) Building will be 100% vacant again. I'm going to: Make improvements to the worst part of the building (common areas) with new flooring and paint. Add additional security lighting at all entrances. Doors/locks are already new as of this year.
4) Our plan to fill units is as follows:
a) Lower asking price to $1,400 (from $1,550)
b) Require 3x monthly rent in income (previously set at 2.5x)
c) No pets being allowed
d) Ask for bank statements to match pay stubs
Those are just a few updates to the screening process my PM has in place. They are doing other credit checks and background checks as necessary. I'm hopeful with a few more updates, starting fresh, and being more selective with our tenants we can get this property turned around.
Thanks everyone for the help!