@Will F we did subscribe to Appfolio and fired the property manager. It was the best decision I've made since I started renting property in 1992.
There is a for sure a learning curve and it's a bunch of work to get it implemented. Appfolio did a great job holding our hand through implementation. We drank the entire Appfolio KoolAid and developed systems around the platform. We forced all tenants to pay on line through the tenant portal. We had two that couldn't figure it out, so we asked them to leave. It has made rent week a snap.
Other friends have seen the progress and want us to put their units under our umbrella now. Not sure how we can do that because no one I work with cares to be a real estate broker and in Minnesota it's required to have a broker's license to manage property. Score one for the brokers lobbying to protect their jobs while adding zero value to society.
Anyway, if you need some help with implementation or have more questions, feel free to ask.
It may seem like $250 a month is a lot, but it's way cheaper than trying to hire someone to do everything the software does. I would never go back.