I live across the country from you and don't know your market. But I think the rent estimates you get online can't be relied on. You need to know and look at your local market. You need to compete with the properties that are available right now. When I market/develop a property I always start with the end in mind, what type of tenant do I want to attract. It looks like you're asking for a decent income ($72k/year) and at least fair credit. The house is large with only 1 1/2 baths. I'm not sure what the market is for that many bedrooms, with only one full bathroom. I don't know the floorplan, but would think you'd have the space to add another bath even if it takes it to 3 bedrooms. Let's say you could add a bath for $10k and increase the rent $250/month. Also add into the equation that the extra bath may attract a better quality tenant and less turnover. That $10k investment just made you $3k/year. That's a 30% return. Likely you could add a bath for less and increase rent even more boasting ROI further. To sum it up, know the local market, it can change quickly based on supply and demand, target the type of tenant that you're trying to attract, look at improvements that maximize your ROI.