@JD Martin Thanks for the feedback. Cashing out doesn't work in my particular case because the houses are in a flood zone. The houses themselves sit high enough that there is little risk of them flooding, plus they're from 1950 and have no evidence of flood damage. A refinance would force me to get flood insurance which would eat away at quite a bit of my profit, otherwise that is exactly what I would do.
I don't mind mixing refi-d and free and clear properties eventually, but right now interest rates are so low I really want to take advantage of that. I'm not looking to build a house of cards, but I can still qualify for traditional mortgages so that seems like the way to go for me.
I always assumed I would buy several SF houses, hold them for a while, and eventually sell some to upgrade to MF. I don't have a goal for a specific number of doors; I am mostly focused on cash flow at the moment.
@Jonathan Tremblay They are technically 2-1, but there is also an office that my tenants have used as a bedroom (the office doesn't have a closet and doesn't have room to add one). They are approximately 1,100 sqft. One is rented for $700 and one for $750. One house had tenants when we purchased it and they have been great. They take good care of the and have very few maintenance requests. The other one took about a month to find a good tenant, but they have also been very low-maintenance.
I've never used the site before, but I just looked on www.rentometer.com and it looks like my rents should be a bit higher. The properties are located between Atlanta Road and S. Cobb Drive, north of Windy Hill. What rents have you been seeing in that area?