Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Dave Lion

Dave Lion has started 3 posts and replied 12 times.

Post: Is Phil Pustejovsky a scam-artist?

Dave LionPosted
  • Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 12

Wow, so sorry to hear that @Ronald Khuon!

Yeah, reading about @Michael Matlock's experience in L.A. really helped a lot ... and Chris' inconsistent answers about that just didn't make sense.  Seems like blaming the student is always the guru's response to why failure happens - it's always the student's fault!

Very grateful to BP for providing this forum to share and learn from others' experiences!

Post: Is Phil Pustejovsky a scam-artist?

Dave LionPosted
  • Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 12

Possible reasons just occurred to me why Freedom Mentor refused my proposal to send them a check by mail:  

1) to avoid giving me a physical address of the operation

2) to avoid violating federal mail fraud laws

Why else would a legitimate business refuse to accept payment by check through the mail?

Post: Is Phil Pustejovsky a scam-artist?

Dave LionPosted
  • Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 12

I just got through the interview process for Phil Pustejovsky's Freedom Mentor apprenticeship program.

3 calls:  

1) 15 minute introductory call from Chris, 

2) 30 minute application call from Eddy, (and written 9 question application after the call)

3) 3+ hours blueprint call from Chris

Interesting experience.  There was no pressure to buy into anything until the final call.  I was "accepted" into the program, hurray, but then came the hard sell ... I had to make a decision during the call, pressured to give payment information (only credit card and wire transfers are accepted, but bank checks are strictly not accepted), tried to convince me I didn't need an attorney to review the documents before signing because everything was written clearly.


Throughout the discussions, I could feel the sell coming ... Chris described the last call as designed to be a test of my ability to make a quick business decision based on the facts, which is the quality Phil is looking for to make his kind of real estate deals.


Many things didn't add up or make sense:

* Chris assured me my area was available, that is, they need to limit each area with only a certain number of apprentices because otherwise it would create competition for their type of RE strategies (selling to highly motivated sellers in distressed situations), and that they have had to turn applicants down in certain markets due to this.  But when I turned this around to ask about the future when I needed to sustain and scale my business, wouldn't I be competing against fellow graduates and future apprentices in the area, how could I continue making money then?  Then Chris said the market is so huge that everyone can have a piece of the pie and be happy, that others can make $1M-$2M per year in much smaller communities of 100,000 or so.  But if that's true, why the initial concern about saturation of my area with apprenticeships?  I suspect they are trying to artificially create a sense of limited supply to increase the perceived value of the apprenticeships.

* I asked whether Los Angeles was a city that may be saturated with apprentices and investors, and Chris said L.A. is big enough to provide an endless supply of deals.  I explained the reason why I asked about L.A. is because I had read former Freedom Mentor apprentice @Michael Matlock's posts about failing to succeed using Phil's method there.  Chris said Michael must have failed because he did not work hard enough and did not have enough dedication to succeed.

* Of the "hundreds of thousands" of applicants to the apprentice program, Chris said only "hundreds" have been accepted.  I asked of these "hundreds," how many have actually "graduated," meaning they reached the $500K profit level (up to which Phil takes a 50% cut).  Chris said he could not say, that it is a good question, and that Phil's answer to this question is "100%" who follow the method and are dedicated to reaching their goal eventually succeed.  He said the average time for a graduate to reach $500k is around 2 years.

* On the surface, some of their deals sound like a licensed broker is required to make the transaction (e.g. negotiating to sell someone else's property directly with another buyer).  Chris said no license is required at all, that such things are done legally in all 50 states.  I asked then why do states regulate real estate agents and require licensing.  He said licensing is required only to make sure real estate agents are operating in an honest and ethical manner, but that anyone can sell real estate in the U.S. without a license.  Hmm .... is that true?  If that were true, why are people convicted of practicing real estate without being licensed?

* When I said I needed legal counsel before signing any agreement, Chris said we can go through the document line by line to make sure everything written is crystal clear, that he would answer anything that wasn't clear, that everything was written in laymen's terms, that others "less bright" than myself have no problem understanding it, and that if I still needed an attorney to review it, that was ok too.  But he said the document was clear enough that having an attorney review it would be a waste of money.

* Chris wouldn't send me the document unless I committed to a method of payment, either by credit card (preferred), or wire transfer (with a definite transfer date).  I said I would pay by personal or cashier's check.  He said they do not accept checks.  Why?  Because checks are not safe, citing their recent lawsuit against "Your Freedom Mentor" (because someone may intercept the check and try to cash it), as well as a previous apprentice's check being lost in the mail.  I countered:  check would be written to Freedom Mentor and sent via certified mail, priority mail, or Fed Ex  - all offer real-time tracking.

Prices quoted to me:  

*  $40,000 deposit for inner-circle, 1-on-1 access to Phil's direct mentoring (vs. $15k or $25k for working with other mentors), refunded upon reaching the first $500,000 in profit

*  $47/month after the first 90 days for up to 10 seller's web-stes, 10 buyer's web-sites, SEO, maintenance, e-Partner account to manage leads and deals. ($197/mo for the $15k/$25k level)

* 50/50 profit sharing for the first $500,000 in profits

In the end, too many things felt shady for me to continue to be interested in pursuing this, and I thanked Chris for his time, and he wished me well.  

If Freedom Mentor operated transparently and legitimately, they would have no problem posting a copy of their contract on their web-site so that it could be freely reviewed by the public.  I noticed the little psychological tricks during the "interview" process and felt I was being manipulated.  My hunch is that of the "hundreds" who have been accepted into the program before, only a small fraction ever "graduate," hence the need for such a costly "deposit" up front to sustain their operation, knowing full well that most will never graduate.

Post: How Do I Find a Good RE CPA for Taxes?

Dave LionPosted
  • Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 12

Thanks Tek!

Post: How Do I Find a Good RE CPA for Taxes?

Dave LionPosted
  • Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 12

Thanks much for all the advice.  I just e-filed my extension.

Post: How Do I Find a Good RE CPA for Taxes?

Dave LionPosted
  • Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 12

Thanks much for the great advice.

Follow up question:  is it important to find a CPA who's local in my area, or is it just as well to partner with one virtually online?

Thanks!

Post: How Do I Find a Good RE CPA for Taxes?

Dave LionPosted
  • Investor
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 12
  • Votes 12

Hello -

First time investor here with a somewhat complicated tax situation (well, complicated to me anyway, lol).  

I am the primary investor / money-man, just started my investments in September 2015, and my rental properties are being managed by 2 separate managing partners in Wisconsin, while I reside in Illinois and have a full time job in an unrelated industry.  

Both rental business partnerships are under LLC's, and the LLC's are pass-through entities for tax purposes. I received a 1099-Misc from one partnership, reporting the net rental income received for 2015. I received no income from the other partnership, as it is not yet profitable. I have also received my W2 from my day job. No other investment income of any sort (besides a puny bank account interest).

My main need right now is someone to help me file my personal taxes and make sure I've reported everything correctly, taken all deductions I'm entitled to, and offer tax guidance for the future.  So, I'd like to find a good CPA to work with long term.  Does he need to be local to my area?  Are the local tax chains (H&R Block, Hewitt Jackson) good enough?  What about online resources like TurboTax?

Would appreciate any advice and references.  If you are an available CPA yourself, please message me with contact info and rates.  I have all my financial documents in order and am looking to file my taxes before April 18, 2015, of course.

Thank you very much,

Dave

Thanks so much for the helpful explanations and examples!  Much clearer now. 

Thanks much for the answers. 

Depreciation ... I've never been able to wrap my head around that concept!  I'll have read up (again) on it. 

Thanks again. 

I'm considering joining into a partnership with a property manager/realtor to buy/sell/rent property. He wants to form an LLC, in which we are both officers. I will provide all the funds to purchase and fix the properties, while he will manage the repairs, rentals, and finding of new purchase opportunities. He has also laid out a schedule of percentage cuts for each of us. Every month, he will prepare a detailed statement of expenses and income, and send me a check for the net amount of my share, which I presume is taxable income. He says when my original investment is returned, then we split the rest equally.

So, my question:  Is the purchase price of the properties deductible as an expense?  Or how does that work?

For example, say I pay $50,000 to purchase a property and another $50,000 to fix it up.  So, my total investment is $100,000.  We rent it out, and then over the next 10 years, my gross share is $100,000, and thus I have recouped my initial investment.  Then we go to sell the property and it is now worth $200,000, which is split evenly, so we each get $100,000 from the sale.

So, presumably, I'm paying 1/3 taxes during the 10 years of rental income, and so I net about $66,000 during that period.  But at the very end, when we spit the profit from the sale, since my original investment was $100,000 and my share of the sale was $100,000, does that mean I don't owe any real estate or income tax for the sale, making my net return on the entire investment $66,000?

Appreciate any help in clarifying this.

Also, I'm looking for a good accountant who is well versed in handling personal income and real estate tax, so please contact me if you know one. I live in Illinois, and the LLC will be formed in Wisconsin.