Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Dave Allen

Dave Allen has started 2 posts and replied 7 times.

Quote from @Tim Swierczek:
Quote from @Dave Allen:
Quote from @Tim Swierczek:
Quote from @Dave Allen:

I'm in a bit of a situation

My wife and her parents are selling a duplex they own together.

My wife is trusting me to re invest into cash positive investments.

We could stand to take as much as a quarter million, and tax free since we lived in the property 2 of the last 5 years.

What are some suggestions for markets that would provide cashflow? I'm looking at Duluth MN because of a video posted on BP, but I recognize this is an opportunity most would dream of, because it's one I've often dreamed of


Well now it's in my lap, and the pressure is on.

Hit me with your scenarios, what would you buy? Where?

Thanks for reading

David


 Do you have any connections or boots on the ground in Duluth, MN? The best deal in the world can get screwed up by poor management. You need a management plan in a market to make it viable. I think Duluth is a good if not great market but it means nothing if you can't execute.

Hey Tim thanks for chiming in, yes I have friends in st Paul who frequent Duluth.

I respect that thought, but Duluth to St Paul is more than two hours each way. That is not a management plan. You will need someone more local who is incentivized to be available to do showings and handle issues. Heirloom Properties has a good reputation with the people I know.


 He would not be managing he just knows the area. I would factor in 6-10% for property management.

i have worked in property management for 3 years before and through the pandemic, and I have been seriously searching for property to invest in for about two years. I currently manage my wife's duplex, and we're hoping to reposition ourselves so we can buy a home to live in and still purchase investment property, but one that can pay for itself.

Quote from @Zeke Liston:
Quote from @Dave Allen:

I'm in a bit of a situation

My wife and her parents are selling a duplex they own together.

My wife is trusting me to re invest into cash positive investments.

We could stand to take as much as a quarter million, and tax free since we lived in the property 2 of the last 5 years.

What are some suggestions for markets that would provide cashflow? I'm looking at Duluth MN because of a video posted on BP, but I recognize this is an opportunity most would dream of, because it's one I've often dreamed of


Well now it's in my lap, and the pressure is on.

Hit me with your scenarios, what would you buy? Where?

Thanks for reading

David


 $250,000 tax-free? Not bad. Why not run it back? House hack another property with a low down payment loan and use the remainder or the proceeds to either renovate or purchase another investment property? 


 I live in California, this is a bay area property.

were not looking to move out of state and house hacking is less palatable when a duplex costs 1.6 million. We have found some fixers farther away for as "little" as 600ks. But the rents don't justify it, for example we are renting a 3 bed 2 bath house with a huge backyard in rancho Cordova for 2350/mo, so duplex rents around here are 1800-2200 ballpark. So you can understand why I was blown away to see prices half that or less with rents 1500-1800 in Duluth. Have done some preliminary research and will do a deep dive, just wanted to see what folks thought of there were any obvious reasons why or why not or any markets similar that I should be considering. I have friends who bought in Texas, Chicago, Minnesota and Tennessee so I've been watching those markets. 

Quote from @Tim Swierczek:
Quote from @Dave Allen:

I'm in a bit of a situation

My wife and her parents are selling a duplex they own together.

My wife is trusting me to re invest into cash positive investments.

We could stand to take as much as a quarter million, and tax free since we lived in the property 2 of the last 5 years.

What are some suggestions for markets that would provide cashflow? I'm looking at Duluth MN because of a video posted on BP, but I recognize this is an opportunity most would dream of, because it's one I've often dreamed of


Well now it's in my lap, and the pressure is on.

Hit me with your scenarios, what would you buy? Where?

Thanks for reading

David


 Do you have any connections or boots on the ground in Duluth, MN? The best deal in the world can get screwed up by poor management. You need a management plan in a market to make it viable. I think Duluth is a good if not great market but it means nothing if you can't execute.

Hey Tim thanks for chiming in, yes I have friends in st Paul who frequent Duluth.

I'm in a bit of a situation

My wife and her parents are selling a duplex they own together.

My wife is trusting me to re invest into cash positive investments.

We could stand to take as much as a quarter million, and tax free since we lived in the property 2 of the last 5 years.

What are some suggestions for markets that would provide cashflow? I'm looking at Duluth MN because of a video posted on BP, but I recognize this is an opportunity most would dream of, because it's one I've often dreamed of


Well now it's in my lap, and the pressure is on.

Hit me with your scenarios, what would you buy? Where?

Thanks for reading

David

Update: It did not help.

We're going to either have to sell or refi to get her off the mortgage or I'll have to purchase investment properties solo.

Quote from @Colleen F.:

@Dave Allen  I don't know if any lenders can comment, they may suggest a different type of loan but if you are half owners  I would think you would split the income but if you were living there I see why you did it the way you did. I  had a different issue on a property and they put a letter of explanation I wrote in the file, but again it was a different issue.  She is however responsible for the loan if they are all on it. 


 Thanks for the comment!

so little update, we're working with my broker/underwriter to find out if having the current tenant sign a new lease with my wife's name added to it would satisfy the requirement, (our side only requires a signed lease because it's a "new rental" so perhaps the other side would be "new" to my wife. I find out Monday I'll post if it works or not.

Hey BP folks!

First post, been reading and listening for years now. Wonder if anyone has run into the issue I'm having

My wife and her parents went in on a duplex together and the three of them are all on the title and loan.

My wife and I are in escrow on a house in Citrus Heights. The loan we were applying for is an FHA, which stipulates we must provide a signed lease for our half of the duplex (to be newly rented out) but for the other half which the parents "own" (in reality all three are equally owners of the entire property.) we would need to provide proof of rental income on our tax return, however her parents claimed that so we seem to be SOL.

The mortgage is covered, we can rent it out no problem, but the underwriter is saying on paper it looks like she is responsible for the whole duplex and the rent for half of it is unreportable. Is this really going to get us dead in the water? The only options that seem available to us are add the parents to our application, remove either parents or wife from the duplex, or in the future put the rents all in my wife's name which might negatively affect my in-laws.

You guys are my Hail Mary, hoping you can spot a solution I'm missing!