Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Daniel Gerardi

Daniel Gerardi has started 5 posts and replied 19 times.

Hey @Ryan Hoover 

it's nice to meet you. I'll be honest I didn't kick start with myself because I didn't think I would be able to contribute much value. I'm not a broker or a wholesaler and the only investment I have made was 2 tax liens in about 2013. I moved from LI NY to Phoenix in february with the decision in mind that wholesaling must be the best place to start for the following reasons.

1. Ease of entry and low cost to get started.

2. An excellent way to start making money on the side along with my day job as an electrician.

3. A way to start learning things like marketing, advertising, business, sales, deal analysis, running comps and the costs associated with purchasing and selling real estate.

4. A way to network with so many individuals like investors, brokers, inspectors, contractors, appraisers, attorneys etc.

But being in self quarantine since february and surfing BP forums I think I have found some flaws in starting with wholesaling. These are obviously based on my needs.

1. Lack of a network of people who have real experience wholesaling and are willing to teach you anything.

2. No MLS access.

3. Having to educate lay people about who you are and what you do, then convince them you are not a scammer out to take advantage of them. This one has been my main driving thought on the subject. While i'm sure some brokers "may" run into this same issue im confident it pales in comparison to that of a wholesaler. I think it would be hard for a seller to say that someone licensed by the state of Arizona to buy and sell real estate is out to scam them and take their house.

With this in mind wholesaling starts to sound like an unnecessary uphill battle. Especially when I realize that being an agent can reap many of the same benefits as a wholesaler. I wanted to keep this as local as possible to Arizona so that maybe if there is something specific to Arizona that I am missing it can be brought to light so myself and others can learn from it.

If I were to kick this thing off with my own experience. It would look something like this.

* I have seriously considered wholesaling as a way to get started learning and earning. But due to quarantine I have become a BP stalker instead for the time being.

* This would have been my first choice because of the wealth of knowledge and experience it can provide. But in light of new information and realizations thanks to the BP community, I am realizing it may not be the best path for me.

* The investments that I have made up until this point have been very lucrative! 2 tax liens that I purchased in 2013 and have since expired and become worthless haha. Some gold and silver over the years as well as some stocks in my Roth IRA. If I could go back and do it differently I would have been much more cautious with my investments in tax liens. And paid more attention to my liens once I had them so I could have taken better advantage of them to make some money.

* I have been Investing here and there over the past 7 years in precious metals and stocks. The writing was on the wall for me that I would have to move out of state some day so I was not comfortable putting down roots in real estate. I am comfortable with the decisions I have made givin my personal situation. But now that the move has been made and we are moved in I am burning to get started, i'm sick of being on the bench.

It's not the prettiest story and there's more to it but it's my truth and I hope this can help someone else.

  Hello everyone ! 

   I'm trying to get an idea of what local investors have chosen to get started on their real estate investment journey. Given the situation with social distancing and avoiding contact with people as much as possible. I think myself and many others can benefit from a discussion like this ! 

 So..... please chime in !

    * What have you chosen to begin with, wholesaling or being a real estate agent? If you started with neither of these jump in as well.      

    * Why was this your choice? 

    * Would you have done it different knowing what you do now?       

    * What kind of properties/deals are you selling multifamily, single family rentals, fix n flips etc.         

    * For how long have you been investing, selling, wholesaling .etc ?     
    * Tell us your story, if there is anything else you want to add don't hesitate.

  I realize this is a common discussion all over BP but my goal is to have the information here be as local and specific to arizona as possible. Laws, practices and what works can vary by state so please keep that in mind.

Thank you in advance for your contributions! 

@Daniel Dietz So you will be putting that strategy into action shortly, I would love to hear how it goes when you do. So i'll just fallow you on BP and hope you update us haha ! In your situation why do you find depositing Roth IRA contributions to your 401k more logical than a joint venture between the 2? I have some ideas as to why but i'm curious what you think.

@Justin Windham

I thought that's what that was, I think it would only be natural to aim for an IRA LLC when the time comes. Especially since I have no interest in collectibles for a retirement account and the added control can be a ++. Bigger Pockets has been an invaluable resource for me thus far and I will be looking more into using IRA's and 401k's with the help of Bigger Pockets and it's major contributers in this area.

Thank you Justin!  

@John Bowens You have certainly given me some more strategies and things to keep in mind. Being able to partner my 401k with my IRA sounds like a useful tool " The juices are flowing !". It's really interesting what you guys are saying about UBIT/UDFI not being as bad as everyone claims. Especially since it's only a matter of time for me when I will start using leverage. When the time comes i'll make it a point to look into it more and not flee in the other direction so to speak. Thank you !

@Daniel Dietz Thanks for being apart of the discussion!

I'm glad there is someone out there with the same questions about this as me. I have considered the use of Roth IRA contributions in the past but not with the idea of depositing it into another retirement account. It's a clever idea and one I hope can be put into action. In your experience have you known anyone to pull off the idea of withdrawing the contributions from a Roth IRA and depositing them into a Solo 401k? Wouldn't this imply that the rules governing where the contributions come from are somewhat flexible on origin, especially if the business spent all of its earnings that year?

@Mike S. Thank you for highlighting some cans and cannots for me as well as limitations on how to contribute funds to a Solo 401k. Those will definitely come in handy to know. @Justin Windham I appreciate you jumping in and backing up what Mike S. says with some of your own personal experience, it bodes well with my inner sceptic haha. Could you please clarify for me a little bit what a Self Directed IRA LLC is ? I believe that's commonly referred to as having checkbook control ? And if you could provide any further useful information on Self Directed IRA LLC's like limitations, rules, tax advantages etc.

Thank you both so much for your input here!

Hi @Will Fraser thank you for you input on the subject!

After some thought on your question as to why I would want to convert my Roth IRA to anything. I like options, while I may not need or use every option at my disposal I feel it's a good idea to know of and have them. Since I don't know 100% what my future needs or wants will be, knowing what ones I have and how I can use them to my advantage holds some value for me. In this particular case with rolling or transfering funds from a Roth IRA to some other retirement account type like a Solo 401k with a whole other set of options for me to take advantage of. This could in my eyes provide me with fluidity (how easily I can move my various funds and investments around within my overall portfolio) so I can have a large variety of things I can do with the same funds instead of them being locked into one location indefinitely. Should I ever need to get creative with how I fund future (which I no doubt will) i'll have some options. That's my thinking at this point in time.

It's not an end all be all decision maker for me to open a Roth IRA account with fidelity just knowing what i'm getting myself and my money into haha. I really like your point about just keeping it simple and rolling a Roth IRA into a true Self Directed Roth IRA and starting a Solo 401k when I can start one. And one that I will seriously consider moving forward.

Thank you Will !      

Hello BP Community ! 

I live in Phoenix AZ and in my quest to choose the best self managed retirement account (for me), that I can fill with a few hand picked investments from the NYSE to grow my wealth for retirement with diversity. I have found that I want a Roth IRA and believe Fidelity may be the best option to suit my needs in the meantime. Moving forward down the road perhaps a few years or so I will want the flexibility of something self directed. Perhaps with larger contribution limits and no limit on income so I can incorporate real estate investments into the mix ( Understanding I will no doubt have to move my money from Fidelity to a brokerage specializing in real estate and self direction). That's when through shuffling around on BP I was introduced to the idea of a solo 401k as a potential option to roll or convert my prospect Roth IRA account into. But soon discovered a Roth IRA cannot be rolled directly into a Solo 401k but a traditional IRA can. I understand I don't qualify for a Solo 401k at this point in time due to me not being self employed yet.

My questions are as follows

* Am I allowed to convert a Roth IRA into a traditional then roll that into a Solo 401k?

* Would it even be worth it? 

* And if this way is a no go is there another way I don't know of yet?

  Any additional information on the subject is of course greatly appreciated, thank you all in advance for your time!

      View report

      *This link comes directly from our calculators, based on information input by the member who posted.