Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Dalton Thornsberry

Dalton Thornsberry has started 2 posts and replied 12 times.

Quote from @Caleb Brown:

1031 it into something else. You can definitely increase cash flow. It has been a great property for you but it's time to trade up. I'd look local first and OOS if nothing looks great. 


 I appreciate this perspective for sure. This is where my mind keeps going. Time for the 1031 and upgrade to something with more doors is the logical situation. Even if I sacrifice a bit of cash flow in the long run a duplex, triplex, fourplex will likely cash flow better as rents increase depending on my entry price. 

Quote from @Justin Moy:

3.7 ROE is pretty low, but with all investing the question becomes what can you do that's better on a risk adjusted basis. 

If you refi you'll have a higher rate, so what does that do to cash flow there? 

Once you get your refi cash where can you put it and at what cash flow will you get? 

Combining those properties, what will it do to your overall portfolio? 

Taking on new acquisitions also brings on new risk. Are the additional returns enough to justify taking on more risk


 It just feels like I'm sitting on capital that can be deployed in a much more profitable manner. I realize my feeling might not match reality with current rates and everything else, and I realize there is a bit more risk but the bottom line at the very least is I could be using that equity to control more $$$ value in Real Estate. Albeit maybe in a market with less appreciation potential or cash flow which seems like the main drawback that I'm running into. 

Thanks! Currently working with a friend of mine who's an agent OOS in a target market to discuss actual rental comps, etc. 

I purchased a SFR (condo) in 2017 for around $130,000. I currently still owe around $111,000 on this property. Rents are $1475 per month and it cash flows about $250 per month after all management expenses, HOA, maintenance, etc.

My return on equity looks pretty bad (roughly 3.7% per my calculation). Current value on the high end would put this SFR at around $280,000. Worst case I sell for closer to $250,000. There are plenty of opportunities out there it looks like to deploy the roughly $120,000 capital (worst case) that I would see from selling in an OOS market. At the very least I could roll this into a duplex or triplex in the same market (Bakersfield, CA) and probably cash flow quite a bit more than I currently am. However, appreciation would likely not be as high on said duplex or triplex.

This feels like a no-brainer even with sky high rates. It feels like I should take that equity and put it into a Multi-Family property as I am only 30 years old and have plenty of time to continue to acquire and build my portfolio. At the very least that capital would allow me to control $400,000+ in Real Estate value v. the current $280,000 or so. If I took said cash from the sell and put it into a $200,000 property out of state I feel I could even cash flow WAY more than the current $250 monthly. 

What are the drawbacks? What am I missing? Need some help navigating this idea. Cash out re-fi would eat all cash flow and I'm not sure it would give me enough capital to tackle a quality property with current rates (I'm locked in at 4.25%).  

Thanks!

Dalton

Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:

It's very simple. Whatever the replacement would be, the IRR of replacement property must be higher than California IRR in terms of absolute dollars.

If you trade a high-appreciation house with cash-flowing property but lower appreciation, it's like selling 1 Mercedes into 5 Kia's. You don't want that.

Everyone in CA is facing the same problem as our IRR is > 28%.


 This is perhaps the best way to put it. I sort of came to this conclusion after a LOT of thought. This property is really high appreciation and imo has a LONG way to go over the next 10 years+. Since I'm in this for the long haul no reason to rush out of the property. 

@Sanjeev Advani I don't think I'm going to sell, I have other ways to snag some capital I'm just having to get a bit more creative. Also, I need to chat with you further in the multi-family space. I get your property updates and emails all the time and recently I've seen some solid deals but wasn't in the position to reach out just yet. I'll keep you in the loop if something that works for my BP and I's criteria pops up. 

@Carlos Ptriawan W-2 job has me in the San Diego area for the foreseeable future. It allows me to invest freely and compound wealth a bit faster. If I ever had back to Bakersfield I'd probably keep this rented and find a new spot to purchase and live in, anyway as RE is cheap up there, relatively speaking hahah. 

@Nick Robinson nah, I've been renting the place for some odd 4 years or so. 1031 would really be my only option at this point. I think I'll just raise rents. 

@Leo R. this is my major hang-up! That's why the Cash Out Refi doesn't really make sense right now. I'm locked in at 4.125%. The properties would be expensive to borrow on but they'd still produce a significant amount more cash flow than I'm currently seeing. The answer might just be raising rents, keeping the cash flow rolling and sit tight until February/March 2023 when I'll have a little influx of capital without pulling anything out. 

Quote from @Steven Foster Wilson:
Quote from @Dalton Thornsberry:

I'm in a bit of a unique situation here, but maybe not so unique as I'd imagine many investors are in something similar right now with recent appreciation, inflation, etc. 

Situation: 

I currently own one rental property in the Bakersfield, CA market that I purchased in 2017. Made some minor improvements and house hacked basically until I relocated for work. I now live in San Diego (my market here is impossible right now imo). The property is now worth almost double what I paid for it. 

Access to the equity in the property is extremely hard to come by right now as HELOCs on investment properties are suspended from any lender I've contacted. I want to gain some working capital to acquire additional real estate in a neighboring market. Cash flow is around $200 a month right now (rent is slightly below market rate as I've had a long term tenant in place). 

I could cash out refi this property but with the rates being what they are and lenders charging pretty ridiculous closing costs, the amortization schedule would not make sense and it would destroy the cash flow I do have in the property (I've worked with multiple lenders and brokers to run the numbers). 

Question:

Do I sell the property, take my $120K in capital and 1031 exchange that capital into multiple, higher cash flowing properties with slightly lower appreciation potential? 

A note: I do have a business partner willing to match that and all together we'd be in control of around $250k liquid capital. With that I do believe we could acquire 4-5 much cheaper properties outside of the existing Bakersfield market (ideally multi-family) and produce a real income to scale much faster (velocity of money and all that jazz). 


HELP!?

Also, I understand this may be the best dilemma ever to have but I want to maximize my use of this equity in one way or another, if the market in CA does cool it would be a great selling point as well. I do think the existing property has more long term potential for appreciation as the area is an up and coming hub in Bakersfield, also close to the University there. 


 It sounds like you need to get the rents up first. I had a long term tenant and I informed the tenant of current market rates and inflation and he was willing to pay market rent, no problem. Have you considered OOS investing? Your money would go further, you could get more properties, and you would build cashflow/appreciation right away. That is in the Columbus Ohio market. I help clients everyday from California find killer deals. I would be running numbers more so that you really know when a good deal is there. https://www.calculator.net/ren... Here is the calculator I like to use. 


 I appreciate the recommendation on looking OOS. I've considered it for sure but never pulled the trigger. I do have family who is in real estate in markets near Little Rock, AK...etc. Overall, I think buying in the markets I know and understand really well is the first step for me and OOS could be a good opportunity for further on down the road.