Hey @Kevin Dickson just so I can get a clear understanding this is a 49 unit Townhome community or is this a portfolio that makes up 49 units? Also what part of South Atlanta is the portfolio located?
So to get started with the analysis, I would definitely love to help you out as I have built a financial model that goes over various metrics of a deal like the NOI, 30 year P&L proforma, the exit (sale/refinance), DCR and some other parameters every investor needs to take into account.
First thing we will need is the trailing 12 of all the income and expenses. Looking at places like craigslist and rentometer is great but you should be basing your offer on the current performance and keep in mind that knowing what the markets rents are important as well for forcing the appreciation (increasing income, rehabbing, reducing expenses)
In regards to the outlay of capital sounds pretty steep with $25k per unit estimate. Just from looking at the rough numbers, this would be yielding a negative return at least for the first couple of years based on your estimates. You need to also think about other expenses like vacancy, insurance, maintenance, taxes, marketing, legal and any other misc expenses related to these properties
So as you can see, there is a lot to keep in mind especially when looking at these bigger deals and it becomes more important in your analysis given the age of the property and how well the previous owner managed the property. Your main focus should be to return your capital that you put in this deal as soon as possible so none of your money is in the deal and your return can then become infinite either through a sale or refinance of the property. For me personally I look to double my money in 3 - 5 years and the investors I bring in to yield them a preferred 8% return and an annual bonus payout based the the cashflow of the property that has no cap with a 35/65 investor split. These are things you want to think about as well because deals like this and possibly in the future you want to bring in investors to get into bigger deals. So factoring in investor payout is important as well and as I'm sure you know you can draw the deal up anyway you would like. All of these I have factored in my model so I can definitely help you out with that analysis as well.
I hope this helps and feel free to message me and we can walk through this together and I can give you examples of my apartments that I own in Macon Ga and how I am analyzing apartments for another purchase this year in the 30 - 60 unit range. This would help give you a better understanding of this deal :)!!!