I survived closing last week- actually had a 2 separate closings but one was a refi on another property - I digress. Closing with the hard money lender took a little longer than expected due to a number of factors- among them the holidays and a way low appraisal. I was, however, able to successfully contest it. We actually had 3 comps in the immediate area that were about $25K-$30K higher for the same size of sfr with similar features- post renovation. We found out the appraiser was using pre-rehab numbers, which is interesting because those properties tended to be distressed sales like mine or quick cash offers.
It was definitely worth it. I only had to come out of pocket with only 10% down and that is for the purchase price and rehab. I'm not sure this is a sustainable approach going forward, however. Distressed sellers likely prefer quick cash closing which this was not. In any event, it is starting out to be a successful BRRRR. I will follow up with the rehab next and tell you about the smelly surprise my contractor found when he visited the house.