Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Cody Dastrup

Cody Dastrup has started 4 posts and replied 20 times.

Quote from @Robert Finn:

You can still acquire a pool property here in San Antonio TX, under 300k. Revenues are roughly in the 80k+ range, most likely higher as we summers are extremely hot! Demand has historically been high for travel with the theme parks, weekly military basic training graduations, medical district, and historic downtown draw (Alamo, Riverwalk, etc).

@Robert Finn I never would have thought about SA as a STR market. I work a lot in Texas and my wife is from Houston and so I've always naturally gravitated toward Tx. Would love to get more info on a high-level, if you have some areas that you'd suggest. I will dm you!

Quote from @Gretchen Quinlan:

Hello! @Cody Dastrup I'm in Utah too and have one property that I'm currently living in but am thinking of buying another and turning this into a STR. The market in SLC seems a bit saturated though for STR.

I'm curious, are you looking out of state because the numbers aren't working in Utah? 

@Gretchen Quinlan I've heard of people (friends of mine) having success near Cottonwood Canyon. I think the theory is that they can charge so much during peak ski season that even in the summer months when it slows down, they are doing well. I've seen their P&L statements and can attest they are doing over 100k annually. However, I'm not sure they are operating in areas where STR are allowed/zoned (so I'd be careful).

I really wanted to make southern utah work. We have both of our STR’s near Zion National Park but it’s extremely competitive, there are a lot of licensing issues, and prices have recently skyrocketed. Our better property is 4 bed 2 bath and we purchased for 370k about 17 months ago. It will do about 65k. The other property we just bought a was already an Airbnb and will do about 40k this year. 

I am wanting to buy something more expensive that can get me more $ for my time. Instead of building a portfolio of 10 properties avg value of 400k, I’d like to buy 5 and $800k each and try to make similar margins. I have a great realtor and lender in southern utah, but the deals just aren’t there. I’ll definitely be investing out of state by the end of the year. In fact, I may even sell that high performing property in order to do so. I’m a year into this and so take my advise with a grain of salt, but I’m not seeing many great opportunities here either. 

Quote from @John D.:

An $800k property that grosses $100k is a 12.5% rent ratio. That's barely break-even after CAPEX, maintenance, a fair amount to pay yourself for property management, etc on some of these large properties.

My last purchase in Lake Havasu was $705k plus $160k remodel and furnishing, will do $160kish a year gross rents(I was hoping for $240k but market has slowed down bigtime).  My last purchase between the Palm Springs / Joshua Tree area was for $800k and $120k remodel and furnishing, will do $220k a year gross rents (I was hoping for more like $300k but the market has changed bigtime, like many).

These larger properties have more overhead, I would encourage you to set your sights higher, especially in this market environment of diminishing prices and lower occupancy.


Sounds like you have properties that cost $630k purchase (plus some upgrades, furnishings, furniture, etc, expenses) that gross $8k a month.  I congratulate you on getting started!  But there are better numbers to be had.  Have you taken a look at some smaller hotels or motels, or similar?  Homes are expensive these days, the prices in hospitality have been beaten down after COVID, given their usual financing methods.

While I know short-term rentals are all the rage, there are small businesses to be bought with much greater returns, that don't necessarily require more time. Home prices have doubled in the last few years, and interest rates nearly doubled as well, which means your main underlying cost on a STR has basically quadrupled. While occupancy and rates are declining vs. the last couple of years. You either need to get REAL good at this business while preparing to make less money, or find a new angle. It's a new reality out here.

@John D. thanks for the thoughtful response. I have about 10 different ideas just from reading this. Will need some time to digest all of the information/suggestions but I can see a ton of value here. 

Quote from @Ryan Moyer:

Hey I live right up the road from you, hello fellow Utahn!

Smokies could probably do that. I've got one in Orlando could do that pretty easily, especially if you're willing to put a little money into the property. There are some hidden expenses in Orlando compared to other markets though (high Fl taxes/ins, high HOA in the resort communities, high utility bills).

$800k-$850k will get you an 8BR in a resort community that projects out to around $100k.  Add another ~$50k-75k of theming to the property and you could increase that revenue number to somewhere in the $150k-$180k range.


 Hello! Just down in AF.

Those numbers blow my mind 😭. An 8 bedroom for 800k that has 50k in Disney theme could do 150k!? That’a crazy. Haha 

Quote from @John Underwood:

When you say revenue, you are saying gross income?

If so I think the more important number is what you keep or net income.

Try putting properties from different areas and price points in a spreadsheet and see were the best ROI is.

Heavy tourist towns like Branson or Pigeon Forge would be places to look.

 Correct. I’m referring to total earnings or income. 

Love how both of the first two comments are telling me to head to the Smokies! Will check it out @Joshua Stein. If you have any tips specific to the area let me know! 

Quote from @Luke Carl:

You can do that in the smokies for sure. Love where your head is at! 

 Thanks @Luke Carl. I've looked at Chattanooga a bunch but they are starting to come down on STR. I'll start looking out there! Do you have any STR's in the Smokies? Any advice you wish you had when you started?

Hey everyone! 

I just secured my 2nd STR and in May entered year 2 of my STR journey. The 2 properties combined should do about 95k in rev next year on about 3.7k in monthly payments ($370k and $260k purchase prices respectively)

I’m wanting to challenge myself a bit on my next purchase and look at something that can do $100k in annual rev.

My question: Are there any markets where properties are sub $800k and doing $100k in annual revenue? 

Quote from @Kevin Luttrell:

Sounds like a sweet deal, but yes like you alluded to you will likely have trouble financing it. Most lenders don't like dealing with manufactured homes in general. Fannie Mae allows single-wides only if they are less than 10 years old, and even then, it will be hard to find a lender willing to lend on it. 

My suggestion would be to call around some local community banks and credit unions. 

 @Kevin Luttrell I may have found one! Mountain America Credit Union out of Utah apparently lends on single-wides. We shall see what they say!

Quote from :

Whats up . 1st of all, congratulations on your work thus far! Awesome accomplishments. So there is a few things to consider here you need to be careful of.

  1. Your single-family residence of 4/2 is not a commercial property. So your "permit" or added income doesn't provide actual appreciation value. The reason why is because appraisers work on a comparable sell model for ALL residential homes (1-4 units), not an income/caprate model like with commercial properties.
  2. However, that doesn't mean someone will pay more for it because it has an STR Permit. Someone might seem more valuable because of that but if they use a loan that still depends on the lender and appraiser, and they don't take into consideration income or permit in its value.
  3. Trailers are hard to get financing for. you have to find a mobile home financing entity or something like that. You should offer if the seller is willing to carry the note on the property.

 @Michael Porche yea, the appraisal is a whole different issues. Luckily I have the resources to throw 150k+ at this, if needed and so it may come down to (if I can even find financing) that this appraises at like $175-200k. If I can get there, I can make up the difference, I just need to get close to the $200k appraisal number if possible and get somewhat favorable terms on a loan. Seems impossible right now, but I'll figure it out! 

@Michael Porche

Quote from @Rachel H.:

@Cody Dastrup You could try asking for owner financing or bringing in a partner or working with a private lender on the deal. One thing to look into is the maintenance and upkeep of the mobile home. There could be items that need to be repaired and/or have deferred maintenance. Hope that helps! 

 @Rachel H.it's in great shape as it's being rented out currently as a STR. Looking into a few options, but nothing that is jumping out at me from a financing standpoint right now