@Andy Luck:
Yes, you are correct that getting emotional can be your undoing. I really don't get emotional with the properties because...well, I just don't.
And, yes we were lucky. I almost didn't buy the place; my brother is a firefighter who told me all about victorians and their lack of fireblocking and how the fire damage could be extensive and unpredictable. I typically don't even consider a building this old because I don't want to deal with all the old stuff like galvanized pipes, knob n tube, lathe n plaster, lead paint, old windows, etc. We made an exception here since all these things had been modernized, and the building showed no signs of structural compromise despite the severely damaged roof structure - as verified by several structural engineers. After many opinions, it seemed like the fire damage was probably limited to the roof, with little to no damage to the vertical structure. We got lucky, as this was the case, but we were prepared for more extensive damage. In addition, we got a fair purchase price for the risk we were assuming and the neighborhood is hot, hot, hot.
Just replacing the roof (which was about shot anyhow), the underlying roofing structure, engineering, permitting, etc, etc was about $45,000. The damage was old - probably from 1987 when the last fire department response was recorded and the vintage of the interior remodeling and system upgrades (plumbing and electric). I suspect that the owner at the time took the insurance money, upgraded the interiors, plumbing, electric, installed new wood windows, and simply slapped a new roof over the charred structure. At the time, this neighborhood was redlined, and the property had recently been sold from the federal redevelopment agency after completing a nearby freeway and hospital project that bisected and essentially destroyed the historic neighborhood.
The before/afters aren't very interesting unless you call an in-kind roof replacement exciting!