Originally posted by @Brandon Turner:
Hard to say. Yeah, it doesn't make for a great rental, so I think I would either stay in it or sell it. However, with a 15 year mortgage, you are actually paying quite a bit of principle down each month. It made your payment higher, but you can handle it -so maybe worst case, you rent it out and break even and in 14 years from now you have a free-and-clear home. That actually sounds kind of intriguing... thoughts @Chris Guthrie ?
Yah I mean looking at numbers had I done a 30 year fixed my payment would fall close to the 50% rule. I'd still try to rent it for $1,500 or a bit more as the properties I was comparing to didn't have all new stuff either and none of them had AC (so if we were to move out next summer and showed it while it was really hot out people will be more aware of how awesome having AC is). Then again I assume the value of the house after the upgrades would mean that it again falls short of renting for the 1% rule though.
So many rules