Thank you all for your thoughtful posts. I recently purchased a triplex (closing target date 9/20/16) and I'll be living on 1 of the 3 floors with my girlfriend. So that essentially kills -$1,050/mo temporarily.
While we are occupying the property:
Effective Income (2/3 units): $1,932/mo
Total Operating Expenses: $1,128/mo
Net Effective Income: $804/mo
PITI: $1,145/mo
Cash Flow: ($-341) ..not bad considering I've been paying $1,100/mo in empty rent checks. I'll most certainly be forwarding my savings towards property #2. I can't wait to refinance out of FHA and get rid of PMI ($180/mo!)
When we leave, it's a different story: $600/mo in cash flow. It's a nice neighborhood on upper Western Ave. in the Buckingham/Crestwood area and it was a requirement that the neighborhood be safe enough for my theoretical children to live there. The downside is that the returns are a bit lower but overall I think it's a great first property. More details to come after closing!