@Account Closed Thank you so very much for the incredibly informative post. You've given me so much to think about! I do think I would like to hang on to the house for a while longer but the layout of the house makes me wonder about it's suitability as a rental. What I mean by that is there is a small loft area carved out of the attic which is beautiful and nicely finished. Its access is via a ladder-like stairway (if that makes sense, kind of halfway between the two) and I wonder if the loft will create liability issues although there are very good handrails there is still an edge that someone could conceivably fall off of if they were being extremely careless. I'm going to have to look into whether this is a problem.
This house doesn't have a basement, only a crawlspace. I could possibly finish more of the attic at some point. My garage is very large and tall and as I said earlier it looks more like a small barn than a typical garage. It has potential although it would need more windows. The ceiling is already insulated and drywalled. There is water out there or at least there was at one point but right now it isn't working and I'm not sure why.
The tiny house idea is brilliant!
Lots to think about! Thank you so much.