Hi Angel,
Welcome to the world of OOS Investing. I'm not too far removed from you - I just purchased my first OOS property this past February after maybe 3 years of prepping myself through analyzing and changing my mindset. Yes, it was partial analysis paralysis, however I also don't think I was ready when I first started looking.
I say, do whatever makes you most comfortable. Turnkey properties have their pros and cons. You going out there, building connections and doing it yourself also has their pros and cons.
Personally, I'm the type of person who will get comfortable in the shallow end, then explore into the deep end until I feel comfortable and understand what I'm doing. That said, I purchased a turnkey property, but not from a turnkey company. I was able to interview my own PM. I went this route because I went in with the mindset that I'm going to make mistakes and similar to you, I don't want to take too large of a bite. I have yet to jump into a (even minor) rehab project, but I know that after a few more properties under my belt, I'll be talking to contractors to expand my knowledge.
Feel free to reach out, I'd be more than happy to discuss!