Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Carini Rochester

Carini Rochester has started 17 posts and replied 516 times.

Post: 19-Year-Old Real Estate Agent in Rochester, NY, Looking to Start Investing.

Carini RochesterPosted
  • Investor
  • Rochester, NY
  • Posts 526
  • Votes 328
Quote from @Eric James:
Quote from @Andrew Thomas:
Quote from @Eric James:

The way you get money for real estate investing is working a job and saving as much money as possible. Also, I grew up in the Rochester area and if you want to be investing in real estate I'd recommend you get out of NY now while you're young.


 Why do you say Rochester is a bad area to invest? 


 Property taxes, income taxes, sales taxes, declining population, unfavorable rental laws, winter weather. And if anything I'd see those things getting worse, not better.


 You do seem to know this area!

Post: Boiler unit on a 4-plex

Carini RochesterPosted
  • Investor
  • Rochester, NY
  • Posts 526
  • Votes 328

I'm pretty familiar with Caledonia and with heating costs in this area. The building is likely an old (100 yrs. or more) uninsulated or under-insulated wood frame building, possibly with the original single pane windows. I think the heating cost that the OP mentioned is reasonable and typical. This winter is running about 6 degrees colder than last year. N.G. is a much cheaper energy than electricity for heating around here. I have experience with both RG&E and NYSEG. N.G. being the cheaper fuel for heating would be true for either of these suppliers. 

Post: Open concept on the way out? (Flip question: to open or not)

Carini RochesterPosted
  • Investor
  • Rochester, NY
  • Posts 526
  • Votes 328

So, Jason, what did you decide to do, and what was the result. Successful flip?

Post: First Residential Rental

Carini RochesterPosted
  • Investor
  • Rochester, NY
  • Posts 526
  • Votes 328

My owner financed deals both came from the church foyer! I'm feeling for this guy and his wife's health. I wish them well. 

@Drew Sygit brings some good insight into the possible pitfalls. Don't go into this without due diligence!

Post: First Residential Rental

Carini RochesterPosted
  • Investor
  • Rochester, NY
  • Posts 526
  • Votes 328

@Obed Calixte is right on! Will you hire a property manager? This seems like a very easy property, management-wise. Manage it yourself. Has owner financing come up in your conversations with your friend from church? This seems like a perfect owner financing opportunity. He may accept a lower than 20% down payment. He may accept a lower rate than bank financing. See if there is any compromise on not raising the rent at all. $300/mo. is a lot to give away. A three bedroom house for 800/mo is crazy low! See if he and the tenant will agree to 900/mo. Then 1000/mo. in the next year. You need some way to jack up this rent.

Post: What’s your thoughts on Owner Financing

Carini RochesterPosted
  • Investor
  • Rochester, NY
  • Posts 526
  • Votes 328
Quote from @Andrew Syrios:
Quote from @Chris Seveney:
Quote from @Andrew Syrios:
Quote from @Chris Seveney:
Quote from @Jason Hathaway:

I'm in the process of purchasing another home adding to my portfolio. What's your thoughts on me setting up owner finance on my property?


Seller financing can be a valuable tool when used correctly, but its effectiveness depends on how it's structured and implemented. While it provides opportunities for buyers who may not qualify for traditional loans, it's important to ensure affordability and long-term sustainability. Some buyers enter these agreements without fully understanding the financial commitment, often influenced by overly optimistic advice. Like any financing strategy, due diligence and proper financial planning are key to making it a successful solution for both parties.


 The biggest problem I see with seller financing is the cost of repairs (as well as holding, selling, etc.) Some new investors think of it as a no-money down deal and given those other costs, it really almost never is. So yes, it's definitely something you need to be careful with. 


 Agree. For those that qualify for conventional financing its another negotiation tool, for those that do not its a way to get into real estate but many do not understand what it is they are signing up for.

Regarding it being good for an owner, again it goes back to the borrower, if I have a borrower with 800 credit and I control cashflow its far different than someone with 540 credit. In the latter I would much rather have my money and be in control.


 All things being equal it's usually not good for the owner unless of course it's a way to get the property sold. If it's to a strong borrower and they just want to invest their proceeds, then its fine. But even then, seller financing is rarely substantially better than another investment they could make (including trust deed lending, which will often be at a higher rate than seller financing)


In my experience, the owners who find owner financing advantageous are at the ends of their careers and are not interested in looking for another investment (other than the usual retirement funding sorts.) They don't want to 1031 into something else. They want to get a monthly check without having to work for it. The big advantage is having the capital gains spread out over many years to avoid a huge tax bill. I have bought two by owner financing from the same seller. I see him a few times a year. He often tells me how much he enjoys getting my payments each month. "Cash flow," he says, "with no phone calls from tenants!" He also told me he probably wants to re-negotiate the balloon payment because he doesn't want the bulk of the capital gains all in one year. That's fine with me. I don't really want to go looking for the financing to pay him his balloon payment. Win/win.

A clean-out at the property line is the norm around here. Why yours is 15' away is odd. The municipality takes responsibility for the portion in the R.O.W. The private property owner is responsible for maintenance on the private property. The camera idea is a good one. When they snake a camera in, they know pretty precisely where the camera is and can see (to some extent) what is clogging the line.

Post: What’s your thoughts on Owner Financing

Carini RochesterPosted
  • Investor
  • Rochester, NY
  • Posts 526
  • Votes 328

Sellers tend to like to finance because it gives them control over when, and how much capital gains flow in and when and how much the balloon payment will be. That's a big advantage over getting the whole amount at the closing. Buyers tend to like to be able to sit down with the seller and negotiate terms. Seller financing is often a win for both parties.

Post: Inherited a property and remodeled it now its ready to sell

Carini RochesterPosted
  • Investor
  • Rochester, NY
  • Posts 526
  • Votes 328

Since you inherited the house, you get the stepped up basis. The fix-up and increased value will not matter to the IRS as long as you sell within a reasonable time frame of the house passing into the estate. (Reasonable time? a couple of years.) You will, most likely own no taxes.

Post: Taxes for 2024 - First rental property purchases in August 2024

Carini RochesterPosted
  • Investor
  • Rochester, NY
  • Posts 526
  • Votes 328

My wife and I did our own taxes using some program (I don't think it was TurboTax, but maybe.) The software steers you through most of the data entry. We had to read some IRS publications when we were uncertain about a few things. @Charles Perkins is absolutely correct about "collecting all receipts, properly tracking all income and expenses and your basis for all assets properly documented and recorded." If you've done all that, its not too hard to enter the info into a tax preparation program. We just switched over to a CPA for our taxes after getting our 6th investment property.